By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Your favorite 3D Zelda game? (POLL)

 

Favorite 3D Zelda game

Ocarina of Time 68 23.78%
 
Majora's Mask 29 10.14%
 
Wind Waker 41 14.34%
 
Twilight Princess (Gamecube) 19 6.64%
 
Twilight Princess (Gamecube) 20 6.99%
 
Skyward Sword 37 12.94%
 
Ocarina of Time 3D 10 3.50%
 
Majora's Mask 3D 14 4.90%
 
Wind Waker HD 32 11.19%
 
I don't play Zelda, See Results 16 5.59%
 
Total:286
Metrium said:
Skyward Sword for me! Best puzzles, great combat and probably best story/characters imo.

I can't understand why WW is so popular. That game has like 3 dongeons... And don't get me started on that boring overworld exploration...

WW HD is my favorite Zelda game after OOT, first game is very charming, game itself looks beautiful, characters are interesting, design of world is very good, all that connection with the sea is great, gameplay is very good. There are 5 dungeons not 3, and I think that are very interesting and not too long, and thats good thing for because I am not big fan of big number of long dungeon.

Only negative thing about game for me was that game need another bigger island like Windfall Island, in that way game would have more content.



Around the Network

Majora's Mask 3D is my favourite. It is such an excellent remake of my favourite Zelda game.
I enjoyed the enhanced graphics, new content, and revamped boss fights.



S.Peelman said:
Metrium said:
Skyward Sword for me! Best puzzles, great combat and probably best story/characters imo.

I can't understand why WW is so popular. That game has like 3 dongeons... And don't get me started on that boring overworld exploration...

I agree on the dungeons, it's why Wind Waker is last place, of the 3D games, for me. Dungeons are important to me, and Wind Waker has too few that are also far less interesting than many others in the series, the game's too easy and bosses are uninspired overal. To me, the only ones that get a passing grade on the Zelda-awesomeness-scale are the Tower of the Gods dungeon and Puppet Ganon/Ganondorf boss battle.

I really love Wind Waker HD dungeons because there not big number of them, they are not long and they are very interesting. Also that's one of reasons why TP is not one of my favorite Zelda games, I think TP dungeons are too long and exhausting and there were 9 of them, but for comparison I liked SS dungeons.

I didnt play original WW but I cant talk about difficulty in that game, but with Hero mode in WW HD I think difficulty was just right. Bosses were OK I guess, I cant say that are bad or great either.



John2290 said:
Well? Twilight princess on Wii, Any who say otherwise are blinded by nostalgia, OoT while good in the late 90s is just doesn't hold up to the qaulity of TP on the Wii port. The controls are masterful. The darker theme, incredible wolf mechanic, the score and the shear consistency of the adventure is amazing. Same old formula but mastercrafted. Skyward sword even failed to reach its level.

Not really mate. I had more fun with Oot simply because it felt fresh at the time, therefore I voted Oot. MM mask time thing annoyed me, TP felt incredibly dated the day it came out, and Skyward Sword control scheme and lack of a Roll button annoyed me. WW over world was a little Meh. All IMO of course. 

 

Here's hoping zelda U is good and we hopefully get a TP HD so I can actually play it like it belongs in the modern era



SJReiter said:
Twilight Princess Wii is my favorite. I really hope TPHD is real.

I hope it's real too, but for different reasons. I thought the game was ugly and fairly empty, a remake may solve these problems making it much more of an enjoyable experience.



Around the Network

Ocarina of time.Not only best 3D Zelda, but best Zelda ever



My (locked) thread about how difficulty should be a decision for the developers, not the gamers.

https://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=241866&page=1

John2290 said:
Well? Twilight princess on Wii, Any who say otherwise are blinded by nostalgia, OoT while good in the late 90s is just doesn't hold up to the qaulity of TP on the Wii port. The controls are masterful. The darker theme, incredible wolf mechanic, the score and the shear consistency of the adventure is amazing. Same old formula but mastercrafted. Skyward sword even failed to reach its level.

Dont agree at all, OoT was not "good in late 90s" it was and it still one of the best games ever. Almost perfect Zelda game with any flaws, also like fact you have 3DS version of basicly same game with just a little better visuals and people even  in 2015. can say that is still great game (offcourse not so great like in 1998. but again great game).

TP even if its great game didnt had nothing really totally new or so great like OOT, and had some big flaws like big world that is completely empty and like criminal utilization of items. I think that SS is better game in almost every aspect than TP expect nonlinearity and backtracking.



Miyamotoo said:
S.Peelman said:

I agree on the dungeons, it's why Wind Waker is last place, of the 3D games, for me. Dungeons are important to me, and Wind Waker has too few that are also far less interesting than many others in the series, the game's too easy and bosses are uninspired overal. To me, the only ones that get a passing grade on the Zelda-awesomeness-scale are the Tower of the Gods dungeon and Puppet Ganon/Ganondorf boss battle.

I really love Wind Waker HD dungeons because there not big number of them, they are not long and they are very interesting. Also that's one of reasons why TP is not one of my favorite Zelda games, I think TP dungeons are too long and exhausting and there were 9 of them, but for comparison I liked SS dungeons.

I didnt play original WW but I cant talk about difficulty in that game, but with Hero mode in WW HD I think difficulty was just right. Bosses were OK I guess, I cant say that are bad or great either.

That's reasonable, to each their own of course.

I agree the Hero Mode in Wind Waker HD is much better, one of the reasons the remaster takes the game to a higher level for me than it was before. The regular mode is the same in difficulty as the original version of GameCube.

Also, I know it often looks like I dislike Wind Waker, reading back my post, it seemed like it was the case yet again. However, a 'least favorite' Zelda game is still an amazing game obviously. In a series where the main games have such a high standard, you gotta get nitpicky.



Nautilus said:
Ocarina of time.Not only best 3D Zelda, but best Zelda ever


Fixed

Ocarina of time.Not only best 3D Zelda, and best Zelda, but probably best game ever.



S.Peelman said:
Miyamotoo said:

I really love Wind Waker HD dungeons because there not big number of them, they are not long and they are very interesting. Also that's one of reasons why TP is not one of my favorite Zelda games, I think TP dungeons are too long and exhausting and there were 9 of them, but for comparison I liked SS dungeons.

I didnt play original WW but I cant talk about difficulty in that game, but with Hero mode in WW HD I think difficulty was just right. Bosses were OK I guess, I cant say that are bad or great either.

That's reasonable, to each their own of course.

I agree the Hero Mode in Wind Waker HD is much better, one of the reasons the remaster takes the game to a higher level for me than it was before. The regular mode is the same in difficulty as the original version of GameCube.

Also, I know it often looks like I dislike Wind Waker, reading back my post, it seemed like it was the case yet again. However, a 'least favorite' Zelda game is still an amazing game obviously. In a series where the main games have such a high standard, you gotta get nitpicky.

Of Course, we just talking about Zelda games. :)

I really hope Nintendo will include Hero mode in Zelda U from start like in WW HD.