By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - metacritic: Metal Gear Solid 5 beat Bloodborne > Fallout 4

 

Game of the Year 2015: MGS5 or Bloodborne?

Metal Gear Solid 5 of course! 99 27.73%
 
100 % Bloodborne! 180 50.42%
 
Both games incredibly, can not decide 25 7.00%
 
see results 53 14.85%
 
Total:357
Paatar on 11 November 2015
97alexk said:

There are more games to be released this year. Including xenoblade chronicles X


Xenoblade would most likely win if it released before the game awards... :/



[Switch Friend code: 3909-3991-4970]

[Xbox Live: JissuWolfe]

[PSN: Jissu]

Around the Network
KazumaKiryu on 12 November 2015
John2290 said:
KazumaKiryu said:

interesting top 3! all 3 are big games : )

guys, dont forget - MGS5 & Bloodborne & Witcher 3 & Fallout 4 are awesome games. 2015 was really great, next year is amazing : D

The best year this century in terms of quality games. And to think all these games give you at least an hour of play for every pound/dollor/euro. For me the most I've paid per hour I played with my top five was around 50 cent an hour with 120 hours on nloodborne clocked and around 20 cent an hour with MGS5 at 250 hours logged. 

Crazy year and I hope this continues in 2016. Horizon is the only game that comes to mind though. Uncharted but that's just a 15 hour event. I think this year will be the highlight of this decade in gaming. 

so: a great gaming-future on console's :)



HoloDust on 12 November 2015

I'd say Witcher 3 has most chance to win, press loved how it changed open-world RPGs - well, at least, lot of outlets thought that.



LudicrousSpeed on 12 November 2015

Still Witcher 3 to me easily, though if the rest of Fallout 4 is as good as the opening act then there will be a new winner.



KazumaKiryu on 13 November 2015

286 people give a answer a poll, great : ) bloodborne, wow. interesting. fallout 7 has now 87 % (ratings, worldwide)



Around the Network
KazumaKiryu on 15 November 2015

ok, bloodborne wins vs mgs5 here on vgchartz, i think ^^ the result is clear, but both games are so amazing.
2016 is coming and then.. Persona 5 vs Uncharted 4 maybe ^.^



DannyDesario on 30 November 2015
97alexk said:
DannyDesario said:
97alexk said:

There are more games to be released this year. Including xenoblade chronicles X

Bloodborne
While the original Xenoblade was the best game last gen, I see this one underperforming from a quality standpoint.  Can't see it getting above an 87.

maybe idk. What quality standpoint do you mean?


Hate that I was right buttttt. http://www.metacritic.com/game/wii-u/xenoblade-chronicles-x       .......84<87



Currently Playing: N/A

Anime and Studying is life RN

DannyDesario on 30 November 2015
DannyDesario said:
97alexk said:
DannyDesario said:
97alexk said:

There are more games to be released this year. Including xenoblade chronicles X

Bloodborne
While the original Xenoblade was the best game last gen, I see this one underperforming from a quality standpoint.  Can't see it getting above an 87.

maybe idk. What quality standpoint do you mean?


Hate that I was right buttttt. http://www.metacritic.com/game/wii-u/xenoblade-chronicles-x       .......84<87


The sad truth is MGS 5, Fallout 4 and X were overhyped



Currently Playing: N/A

Anime and Studying is life RN

StokedUp on 30 November 2015

As a huge metal gear fan, I was left slightly disappointed with MGSV. So much I havnt even finished it. It baffles me how it can score so high when deep down its a very repetitive game. Havnt played Bloodbourne or Fallout 4 yet but I will do I can see myself liking them both better than I have MGSv.

But it's all personal opinions.



PSN ID: Stokesy 

Add me if you want but let me know youre from this website

patronmacabre on 30 November 2015
DannyDesario said:


The sad truth is MGS 5, Fallout 4 and X were overhyped

While there was a substantial backlash against MGS V for its story and because people felt it was incomplete, I think its phenomenal gameplay greatly outweighs these problems.

I think that, while it's trendy to knock on MetaCritic, I don't think MetaCritic is a poor indicator of quality. Bloodborne, The Witcher 3, MGS V, and Undertale are the highest rate games (that we care about) and are almost unquestionably the best games of 2015.