metacritic: Metal Gear Solid 5 beat Bloodborne > Fallout 4

[patronmacabre]

DannyDesario said:

The sad truth is MGS 5, Fallout 4 and X were overhyped

While there was a substantial backlash against MGS V for its story and because people felt it was incomplete, I think its phenomenal gameplay greatly outweighs these problems.

I think that, while it's trendy to knock on MetaCritic, I don't think MetaCritic is a poor indicator of quality. Bloodborne, The Witcher 3, MGS V, and Undertale are the highest rate games (that we care about) and are almost unquestionably the best games of 2015.