2016 and it's not even close. This year has been pretty awful for me. I honestly think it may have been one of the worst ever for me. 2016 is looking to be amazing and I'm sure there's still many surprises coming, so assuming everything doesn't get delayed, next year may honestly be close to one of the best years ever.

I like 2015 cause of Halo 5 splatoon and xenoblade but 2016 looks really good too. I thought 2015 was really good though.

2015: Majora's Mask 3D (new Zelda for me), Splatoon, Yoshi's Woolly World, Super Mario Maker and Xenoblade Chronicles X

2016 games I'm looking forward to: Genei Ibun Roku #FE, Pokken Tournament, Zelda U, TP HD (if real), Fire Emblem: Fates, Horizon: Zero Dawn, Ratchet & Clank, Persona 5.

Could go either way I suppose.

2016 for all consoles

Assuming most titles actually hit and function properly in 2016 then it will be a fantastic year.

2016, no contest, this year has been dreadful.

If I might be a tad snarky, I think the only people saying either year is the best are tweens that just started gaming a few years ago. XD

Both don't seem that good, especially for Nintendo

but I'll go with 2016 because Zelda U (hopefully) + Genei Ibun Roku + FE Fates (maybe)
compared to
Splatoon + Xenoblade X

Are you a Nintendo only gamer? I was asking because both the XB! and PS4 have loads of great looking games linded up for next year. I don't know much about the Nin lineup ourside of Zelda and Pokemon so I can't really speak on that one.

No Man's Sky is in 2016 and Uncharted 4. but 2015 had Bloodborne and Fallout 4......... Tough call lol