I'm just going to retort and then I'm going to lay down my proposal to you zero.
1. I though long and hard about this because my info surely is your lynchpin. Ie, you would pretty much be instantly lynched for not following the plan.
However, the only way for town to win is to take out mafia here. And if you are the sk, then that will be against my win condition to lynch you.
2. I don't know what to tell you. Meta gaming the setup is not evidence. Concern over how many investigatory roles (2) comes off as complaining about how hard you had it.
3. Yours is the only role so far that is weird. If you are so against 2 investigatory roles, for what merit do you justify two protective roles?
4. Your theory about Mike and Xander doesn't make any sense actually. I knew Mike was the cop, and left him alive, with no roleblocker... I watched Mike because he was the most confirmed player we had and therefore a prime candidate for nightkill. Our protector (you) instead decided to protect himself instead of the most important town that night, and doctor was also nowhere to be seen. So kudos to you for not protecting anyone this game. And yes, that is another strike against your role, because a protector should be protecting the most important players. Instead, you protected yourself, a player who through the majority of that day, was going after what we now know as a town cop. Secondly I don't see the roles of people I watch. I see who targets them.
5. You protected xander?? For the love of god, he is a lynch candidate! And Mike is STILL fucking out there in the cold. I would have told the truth if you protected yourself, I even went so far as to say you MIGHT have protected yourself and blocked my ability. Yet here you're saying I would've lied even if you did. I gave you the benefit of the doubt, and you still try and discredit me. We had a plan, an agreement, and you risked that to protect a player like xander?!? Remember, I'm the one who thinks xander is your teammate, and I've written in a post, which I can quote for you again, that in my experience an sk duo can sometimes protect but never the same target twice in a row, and that your buddy may be protected instead, and now you come to me and tell me that instead of sticking to the arrangement, you decided to play a fa st one and protect a player whom everyone suspects, instead of targeting really the most valuable player we had, mike. If you weren't going to hold to the arrangement, you should've said something so I wouldn't have wasted my power watching you and might have actually found a killer last night.
6. Again, meta gaming the setup is not evidence. Like you said, we have no idea what the mafia roles are. It is very common for mafia to have a bulletproof, and also kills that go through protection , and sometimes a stealth kill that can't be seen. Last game I played as mafia we had one of each of those things. There is oftentimes also a godfather who can't be scanned by a cop. Sk usually has all of these things put together. I don't think the games been unfair at all because even with all these supposed town roles, we have not been able to stop anything or find any mafia other than one who broke down when a gentle breeze came his way.
7. It's sad that your two most trusted Townes are Mikes top suspects.
Anyway, here's my proposal.
If you are the sk, it is not in towns interest to lynch you. We need you alive to hopefully kill the mafia. So, with that being said, I need to know if you are the sk or not. If you are, I will leave you alone and look at someone else. But you need to tell me right now if you are the sk or not.
