As the thread title asks: which one do you think can provide more memorable gameplay experiences, Kinect or VR, in your opinion?

One allows you to use your whole body and voice to control the gameplay, the other is more about immersion as you use your controller.

What say you?

I guess this is a reply to Phil Spencer's recent statements diminishing the potential of VR gaming. Isn't it?

Well, If I have to pick between 2 evils. I'll go with VR, at least its gaming focused and I can play without the need of using or even having a television.

I choose neither, just in case anyone wants to know.

how is that even a question? VR without a doubt.

I dislike both to be honest.

The majority has voted Kinect down so the answer is obvious.

Should have made this a motion control vs VR thing, instead of a Kinect vs VR thing.