Halo 5 will win, easily. Battlefront has no single player campaign, so it's going to lose out on alot of sales.

BF PS4 > Halo> BF XB1

One day I wanna meet all those people that apparently buy games like Battlefield for the singleplayer campaign.

There's more people who beat Battlefield 4's campaign (49%) than ones who have gotten to rank 25. Pretty similar tasks.

http://www.trueachievements.com/Battlefield-4/achievements.htm From 85k gamers on Xbox. A Multiplayer focused console.

Believe it or not, people do see value in a single player even if it is sub-par. 

Isn't that why some gamers didn't like Titanfall? While yes, some of it had to do with content itself.

I use to buy COD for the single player. Bought Battlefield and beat the campaign and hardly played the Multi. I'm not that good at those multiplayers tho

I know that there are people that care about campaigns in these games (though I do have doubts about how representative data from something like trueachievements is), but I don't really get why, if the campaigns were any good then sure but they aren't and people know that I think.

Also I think the main reason for people not liking Titanfall was lack of content, the campaign was just part of that.

I think it does a good job of giving data. There's also 40k 360 players you could add to that 85k. That's a damn good amount of people to get data from. 

When looking at comment sections like this:( http://www.ign.com/articles/2013/06/24/why-titanfall-has-no-single-player-campaign ) campaign seems like a really big problem with most of those gamers.

Halo 5 will sell more than the combined console versions of Battlefront.

Battlefront will disappoint slightly, I think, and its lack of SP has already hurt sales even before the first reviews come along.

I know it would seem that way, the about 370k owners on psnprofiles show a similar picture but I quite simply doubt that EA CEOs or whoever would say that people don't play the singleplayer in these games if he didn't have the data to back it up (and EAs data is going to be significantly more complete than ours here)

And if Titanfalls multiplayer had enough content then people wouldn't have complained about a missing singleplayer, content was the core problem and a singleplayer campaign would have been a way to help solve that problem.

Content is also a core problem in Battlefront. People are upset that EA is using the name yet leaving out features and content from previous games. Essentially making it a multiplayer Battlefield: Star Wars.