They should add another category: the OMFG category.

2015 Winner : Shenmue III

If we're going by views, Fallout 4 beats it by 4.5 million. Trailers don't account for much, so hopefully we get more info in the Fall.

Out of curiousity, here are the top viewed E3 2015 videos

1 - Fallout 4 Official Trailer - 15,032,744

2 - Star Wars: Battlefront Multiplayer gameplay - 11,915,476

3 - Final Fantasy VII Remake Trailer - 10,421,206

4 - Destiny: The Taken King Reveal - 7,693,027

5 - FIFA 16 Gameplay Trailer - 6,667,630

That's a good representation of E3, and makes understand why sony won E3, with the best new IP and Uncharted 4, not only because of 3 megatons and Nier and Star Ocean 5

My guess line up with their awards on: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=7402186

Best Console Game
Best Handheld Game
Best PC Game
Best Action Game
Best Action/Adventure Game
Best RPG
Best Sports Game
Best Family/Social Game
Best Indie

I guessed / rated alot of them the same way they did.... 9 / 14 guesses isnt bad.

Was not at E3

Well I disagree with the best multiplayer, best independent game and best racing game winners, and I think Fallout has won too many awards.

Star Wars definitely had the best MP, so is say it deserved it. Halo was messy. Uncharted and Horizon both deserved their awards. Don't know how I feel about Fallout 4 tbh. The spectacle of No Man's Sky alone in site made it the choice. Neither racing game looked interesting to me.
Sport games shouldn't be voted on either.....

I feel like best of show belonged to Horizon:zero dawn, not fallout 4.
Apart from that more or less agree with everything else.

I guessed 9 out of 14 the same as them after all.

@MoHasanie

Halo multiplayer showing at E3 wasnt good, to be honest.

Id be surprised if it won that catagory.

I think Starwars Battlefront or Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege. should have won the best online multiplayer award.

Fallout 4 is not deserving of best of show to me and it really has to do with quality. Bethesda products are unfinished, have endless bugs, poor writing, and silly design decisions, but people praise them for it. Fallout 4 looks to be no different, and the hype has overtaken once more. Will it be a solid release and experience? Definitely, but awarding products that are borderline unfinished is a slap in the face to any developer who cares. It's insulting and it really does piss me off.

Only Fallout 4