By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Who won the E3? THE VGCHARTZ-VOTE Thread - You decide!

 

Who won the E3 ? @ All VGChartz User

The PlayStation 4 (Sony) 1,279 68.03%
 
The Xbox1 (MS) 279 14.84%
 
nintendo digital event 105 5.59%
 
see results 217 11.54%
 
Total:1,880

Anyone who suggests that Sony didn't have the best presentation this year is ... well I don't think I can say this and stay on the site.

Simply a better presentation in every way.



Around the Network
sales2099 said:
deskpro2k3 said:


Last time I checked, FF7 is not on any xbox console.

The rest of this year is in good hands with Persona 5, until dawn, god of war III remaster, uncharted collection, no man's sky, rime, tearaway, everyone's gone to rapture, wattam.

Last time I checked, FF7 remake is timed exclusive to PS4 and will come to Xbox One. You know what I meant.

That list is composed of remakes and B titles/indies. With No Man's Sky being the exception and possibly 2016. Its happened..... its 2011 again, except PS4 fans are defending Sony for the remakes and indies and Xbox fans are bragging about having more AAA games.

This is trippy :P

First off, first on Playstation does not indicate at all that the remake of Final Fantasy 7 is ever coming to the Xbox One.  There's very good reason to believe that Sony still has publishing rights of Final Fantasy VII in the US and Europe.  There's also rumors from actual journalists that Sony had to partially fund the remake in order for Square Enix to agree to it (since they can't put the title on other consoles).  If that's the case, it won't ever appear on Xbox One.  For instance, the PC version of Final Fantasy VII isn't coming to Xbox One.  It would obviously sell well enough and be easy enough to port, so why wouldn't it appear on Xbox One?  A little common sense indicates that it probably can't without Sony's permission.  The same is true of every other Final Fantasy VII related game.  You're looking at the phrase and ignoring the history and the likely scenarios that are attached to it.  Sony gave the permission to put Final Fantasy VII on PC.  Likely it was part of the original contract.  That contract probably has no expiration date.  It probably also includes everything related to Final Fantasy VII.  If that's the case, you'll never see this game on Xbox One.  It likely is the case. 

Furthermore, Persona 5 is NOT a B title.  Persona 4 sold 2 million copies overall.  Calling that a B title is ridiculoously ignorant.  Persona is the third best selling JRPG series next to Final Fantasy and Star Ocean.  This one has a lot more mainstream appeal as well and is getting media attention that Persona 4 never got.  I'll be surprised if it doesn't hit 2.5 million in lifetime sales honestly.  People love Persona, and you're ignorant on the topic.  Until Dawn isn't a B title either.  It's likely that it won't live up to Quantic Dream fame, but it definitely has high production values.  Sony's line up is good enough to push sales considerably over Xbox sales worldwide.  A little less salt buddy.  I like the variety that Playstation offers a lot more than Microsoft's exclusives.  You obviously don't feel that way.  Nier and Star Ocean 5 are huge announcements for me.  They obviously are not for you.  That's perfectly fine, but stop pretending that everyone loves Halo and Gears.  They don't.

It's really hilarious that you think the entire internet is suddenly a Sony fanboy because the response is overwhelmingly that Sony won E3.  We're not all fanboys buddy.  I love games on all platforms.  I definitely enjoy JRPGs more than most people, so I naturally gravitate to the PS4.  That being said, Gears of War 4 actually looked pretty good to me.  So did Recore and I do want to play Quantum Break.  I might actually buy a Xbox One if Microsoft has an equally interesting E3 next year.  They're interesting me way more than they did last generation.  And I think that's a great thing.  I'm already buying a Wii U for Xenoblade Chronicles X and Zelda.  I own a gaming PC already.  We're not fanboys, we just like what we like.  Get over it.



I think Sony kept the best momentum up throughout their conference.

Both they and Microsoft showed promising new IP, though I am disappointed with the stock-standard conferences they deliver these days.



starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS

Sony by a country mile

MS was good

Nintendo....was not....



I laugh very hard as some that mention that FF7 is timed exclusive and then add the new tomb raider as part of the list as to why MS won. Guys you have to be consistent, timed exclusive count or don't count?



Around the Network

Honestly, for this year, I would vote for either Bethesda or the PC showfloor presentation.

The fact that most people associate this E3 with (for Microsoft) the 360 backwards unlock (boring, us Nintendo fans have had this feature for years, move along), (for Sony) a game that was promised around 7 years ago on a previous console, and (Nintendo) an absolutely terrible showing all pointing signs towards Nintendo moving on to the NX is just sad for the big three. When backwards compatibility (something that all companies should provide for at least 1 prior generation, from the beginning) is the most exciting news, that is saying something.

Bethesda has freaking Fall Out 4. And as a PC gamer (though mostly Nintendo fanboy) myself, I have to say hearing that No Man's Sky is coming to PC was the most exciting thing I heard. That game just looks so huge and so wonderful!!! Who ever is developing that game won E3 in my eyes!



Definitely Nintendo because Metroid Federation Force looks ammaaaaazzzzzzin and definitely not an attempt to cash in on the Metoid brand.



Honestly think we will see them at gamescom, seems better from all view points, This way the momentum will stick through the holidays or that is the hope. However they could just not drop price. We will see.



yvanjean said:
Madword said:
Compared to Microsoft conference highlights where they had Backward compability (din't see that coming), mods coming to Fallout 4 big announcement (I don't care if it's exclusive to Xbox one and added bonus of Fall out 3 for free), new elite controler (surprising after previously announce new Xbox one controller with 3.5 MM jack), Recore new IP, Rare Replay and new IP Sea of Thieves, Gears 4, I'm actually excited about Halo 5 and Rise of Tomb raiders that are coming this year (both had a good showing).


But what you are saying is highly subjective.

Note Fallout Mods are coming to PS4... not really that amazing news.
Backward compatibility - this was a crowd pleaser, but it's not a new game, it's old games.
Rare Replay - a collection of old rare game - not even remasters..
Sea of thieves - doesn't look that great and is going to fail and i don't know why thats the best rare could come up with - a multiplayer game...gah
Gears 4... didnt look that great, shown too early
Halo 5 - Not particularly exciting gameplay - multiplayer looked stale in comparison to Doom and Battlefront
Tomb Raider - presentation was quite poor - didnt show any evolution from the previous entry, looks like the same game
Elite controller - errrm ok, £90 odd quid for another controller, very limited appeal.. ok yeah thats exciting gaming news...
CGI Trailers with no gameplay (again)

This is why i thought MS's show was poor. I mean they spent so long on hololens a product that is going to do nothing in the world of games.

Backward Compatibility - is huge news. Fans #1 request on both consoles and we're getting some free games with Fall out 4 and Siege games.
Recore - This game is huge, Sony already has more establish development house and Microsoft struggle to get exclusive to match Sony's. This game was totaly unexpected and I can't wait to play it.
RARE - I think your being subjective on this one...Sea of Thieves - This is very interesting effort by Rare and I'm glad to see they're not doing Kinect game anymore. The game also coming to PC so not the biggest exclusive IP, microsoft fans wanted. Rare replay is pretty huge news, especially that it's coming this summer and only going to cost $30.

Gears 4... It's not Uncharted 4 or Horizon.... but come one it looked amazing... the game gave you a small preview on what to expect more GEARS. They showed that the game will retain the exciting two players coop campaign. This game is a big Holiday 2016 titles.
Tomb Raider - More of the same from one of the best game of last gen is exactly what we should be asking and the key point made during the conference more focus on TOMB RAIDING. One of my biggest pet peeves when playing Uncharted games is the numbers of enemies you have to kill and more tomb raiding is exactly what I want from Rise of the Tomb raider. It's a huge Holiday 2015 game, from what they shown I fully expect high metacritic on this game.
Halo 5 - If you never liked Halo, Halo 5 not going to get you pump. I've played the beta the multiplayer going to be amazing. Warzone was a very pleasant surprise, the campaign look has top notch has in previous games. Can't wait to get this game.  Well Battlefront is star wars obviously that looked amazing regardless of what game your comparing it. 
Fallout 4 - Mods coming to is very big console news regardless is if coming to PS4, Fallout 4 is one of the biggest game this year and Xbox one getting exclusively Fallout 3 with Fall out 4 is pretty big news. 

The fact that you actually calling the show poor is extremely subjective. This is by far one of the best Microsoft showing. 

Microsoft>Sony>Bethesda>>>>>Ubisoft>>>Square>>>EA>>>Nintendo

Forza Motorsport 6 has weather.  I thought this was the best demo/trailer/announcement ever.  Next was Halo 5's warzone, and lastly EA's NFS.



Favorite Game Franchises-

Gran Turismo, Forza, Project Gotham Racing, Need for Speed, Burnout, TOCA Race Driver/Race Driver/Grid, Colin McRae Rally/Dirt, Halo, TimeSplitters, Splinter Cell, Gears of War, Borderlands, and Call of Duty.

Let's just say I love racing games followed by shooters and the Xbox One has filled this love.

padib said:
Hynad said:

I don't remember seeing the annoucement that you became a moderator. Surely I missed the memo.

As for the rest, considering our history, I would ask that you don't interact with me ever again. But since you did, I will direct you to my edited comment, which was edited before I noticed your backseat moderating comment:

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=7368375

Thank you. And I hope you won't reply to me again.

Stop attacking people. Stop attacking Sales, stop attacking me, stop attacking people who disagree with you, stop calling people names, stop being rude, stop what you're doing because you are making this place negative. And if I do it feel free to tell me to stop too.

I hope to keep replying to you for as long as I can to make sure you stop being negative in this place. I don't need to be a moderator to care about the wellbeing of the forum and the people here. I don't need to be a moderator to tell you to stop. I just need to be a person who's had it and who wants things to change.

If the mods won't do it I will continue to tell you to stop because I know what you're doing: you're bullying people and causing people to gang up on other users just because they have an opinion you don't like.


He threw a rock. I reacted to it. I'm far from being negative. 

Now, respect my request and don't talk to me again.