By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Who has the best exclusives in 2015? X1 or PS4

bouzane said:
AnthonyW86 said:


Tomb Taider is exclusive in 2015. I get that those games might not appeal to you but then saying it's one sided is an overstatement. If i were to look at it that way the PS4 list would be completely empty except maybe for Rime. Also the XBone exclusive will easily outsell any of the PS4 exclusives.


I admit that these are both salient points. Who cares about what sells more though, that is not relevant to this thread. The OP asked what games appeal to me and I replied honestly. For me the XBOne only has Inside, Halo 5 and Tomb Raider and I'm not going to buy the Xbox version of Tomb Raider.


I'd wait and see if it does come to PS4, as things change. If ROTR sells well on the XB1, it may not even go to the PS4. Also, just because its timed, doesn't mean its coming to the PS4.



Around the Network
super6646 said:
bouzane said:


I admit that these are both salient points. Who cares about what sells more though, that is not relevant to this thread. The OP asked what games appeal to me and I replied honestly. For me the XBOne only has Inside, Halo 5 and Tomb Raider and I'm not going to buy the Xbox version of Tomb Raider.


I'd wait and see if it does come to PS4, as things change. If ROTR sells well on the XB1, it may not even go to the PS4. Also, just because its timed, doesn't mean its coming to the PS4.


Who said anything about a PS4 version? I'm waiting for Tomb Raider to be released on Steam. I will buy an XBOne years from now and will grab Tomb Raider if it never gets ported, in which case I would certainly consider it a feather in the Xbox's cap.



bouzane said:
super6646 said:


I'd wait and see if it does come to PS4, as things change. If ROTR sells well on the XB1, it may not even go to the PS4. Also, just because its timed, doesn't mean its coming to the PS4.


Who said anything about a PS4 version? I'm waiting for Tomb Raider to be released on Steam. I will buy an XBOne years from now and will grab Tomb Raider if it never gets ported, in which case I would certainly consider it a feather in the Xbox's cap.


Oh, your talking about steam. Still a wait and see.



super6646 said:


Ok. How about we make a bet. If terraway sells 1/10 of Halo 5, you win! If you lose, you admit I won in your sig for 6 months. If I lose, same goes the other way. Clearly sales are an indicator of which is more popular with the public. So we got a deal?

Do you have an alt?

There's some guy in the music thread going by the name of "xxxBeiBeRxxx" that swears Justin Beiber is the best thing since sliced bread, convinced he's music is awesome! Must be right hey. Sells millions and most watched guy on youtube.

Sales do not equal quality. You should know that. If you can't see the quality in games like Either One, Everybody's gone to the Rapture and No Man's Sky then that's down to your personal taste. Nothing wrong with that but you need to stop saying the PS4 is all quantity and no quality because it's simply isn't true. You should never bring sales into a thread about how good games. Millions sold do not add extra quality.



super6646 said:
Aerys said:


And you cant tell Halo 5/Rise Of The Tomb Raider ( soon on PS4 btw, so that doenst make any sense to put it in the list, when we will look back, the exclusive list on One will look a lot  smaller without this big game after the PS4 release )  outshine this, they are too much different but it is sure not a small phone game


Ok. How about we make a bet. If terraway sells 1/10 of Halo 5, you win! If you lose, you admit I won in your sig for 6 months. If I lose, same goes the other way. Clearly sales are an indicator of which is more popular with the public. So we got a deal?


I knew you were talking about sales. You keep saying quality but now you're talking about sales. The sales of a game have nothing to do with the quality of the game. We will get Tearaway which will probably get around a 87 and then Persona 5 where all the mainline games have been around a 90. Including Bloodborne, that's 3 very high quality titles. What does Xbox have this year? Halo 5. Forza 6 will probably be around Forza 5 which was a 79. Oh and we even might get a Uncharted Collection and looking back at last year I saw people using HMCC as a quality game for their 2014 list. So that's 4 quality games vs 1 quality game on Xbox One. Well we have quality and quantity.

I doubt Halo 5 will have a higher metacritic score than Bloodborne.



"There is only one race, the pathetic begging race"

Around the Network
super6646 said:


I'd wait and see if it does come to PS4, as things change. If ROTR sells well on the XB1, it may not even go to the PS4. Also, just because its timed, doesn't mean its coming to the PS4.

This is just wishful thinking. They aren't going to ignore a large chunk of consoles users unless MS pays more to make it full exclusive.

Not only ignoring PS4 cost them millions of sales but also compromise sales of future sequels on the PS4.



bouzane said:
super6646 said:


Then I stand corrected. Even so, you can't tell me this outshines something like Halo 5 or Rise of the Tomb Raider.


He certainly can say that. The thing about opinions is that they are subjective. I am personally looking forward to being able to play Tearaway far more than yet another Halo sequel. Fun fact, Tearaway and Halo 4 have the same score on Metacritic (not the same user score though).

I can say the same, Halo stopped to be interesting for me since Halo 3, i feel nothing anymore for this game, the third was too much, it just felt dull compared to the previous ones, maybe because my main interest in Halo had always been single player

 



Predictions for end of 2014 HW sales:

 PS4: 17m   XB1: 10m    WiiU: 10m   Vita: 10m

 

super6646 said:
Aerys said:


And you cant tell Halo 5/Rise Of The Tomb Raider ( soon on PS4 btw, so that doenst make any sense to put it in the list, when we will look back, the exclusive list on One will look a lot  smaller without this big game after the PS4 release )  outshine this, they are too much different but it is sure not a small phone game


Ok. How about we make a bet. If terraway sells 1/10 of Halo 5, you win! If you lose, you admit I won in your sig for 6 months. If I lose, same goes the other way. Clearly sales are an indicator of which is more popular with the public. So we got a deal?

I seriously hope you're joking, it's unthinkable that someone could use that logic on this subject...  hopefully you are just too young and not yet open minded then.


I dont want to be despising but...sorry, i cant make such bet, i'm not that kind of guy, someone who prefer one game/thing over an other because it's more popular cant be called a gamer/guy with personality

I dont care if Justin Bieber is more popular than an other great artist, it wont make him more interesting to my eyes.

 

Damn, if we want to talk about sales, we have threads for that, here we talk about quality, sales and popularity have nothing to do with quality



Predictions for end of 2014 HW sales:

 PS4: 17m   XB1: 10m    WiiU: 10m   Vita: 10m

 

Aerys said:

I can say the same, Halo stopped to be interesting for me since Halo 3, i feel nothing anymore for this game, the third was too much, it just felt dull compared to the previous ones, maybe because my main interest in Halo had always been single player

 


I too play Halo for the single player (I can think of plenty of FPSs I'd prefer for multiplayer) but I actually enjoyed Halo 3. Maybe it was because I had really low expectations due to the fact that I hated Halo 2's shoddy, poorly made campaign. Did you try Halo: Reach, I thought it was the best in the series?



bouzane said:
Aerys said:
 

I can say the same, Halo stopped to be interesting for me since Halo 3, i feel nothing anymore for this game, the third was too much, it just felt dull compared to the previous ones, maybe because my main interest in Halo had always been single player

 


I too play Halo for the single player (I can think of plenty of FPSs I'd prefer for multiplayer) but I actually enjoyed Halo 3. Maybe it was because I had really low expectations due to the fact that I hated Halo 2's shoddy, poorly made campaign. Did you try Halo: Reach, I thought it was the best in the series?


I remember i had it but i dont remember the game at all ( it was the one with the shield ? ) so it didnt make an impression for me.

The epicness of Halo CE was something i never found again in any other Halo , some could say it's because of nostalgy but i can still enjoy other FPS's ( even if they become rare, i'm not so much into FPS anymore i think, since COD 4 , maybe my tastes just evolved)



Predictions for end of 2014 HW sales:

 PS4: 17m   XB1: 10m    WiiU: 10m   Vita: 10m