By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Xenoblade Chronicles X Needs to be on another system

 

Xenoblade Chronicles X on PC

Yes 101 13.76%
 
No 632 86.10%
 
Total:733
DavidKell on 14 April 2015
daredevil.shark said:
Congratulations. This thread is news. Lol.

http://playeressence.com/xenoblade-chronicles-x-is-a-first-party-game-nintendo-owns-96-or-more-of-monolith-soft/


Yea i saw that i don't know whether to laugh or cry (been reading to many Wuxia lately). 

I made a mistake about and didn't check about ownership of monolith (my instinct kept telling me to check but lol).

Honestly tho i just want RPG, good rpgs to sell more so instead of having no wild arm, no suikoden, no lost oddyssey ect.

These type of series will florish and new ones will be made.



Around the Network
bigtakilla on 14 April 2015
DavidKell said:
daredevil.shark said:
Congratulations. This thread is news. Lol.

http://playeressence.com/xenoblade-chronicles-x-is-a-first-party-game-nintendo-owns-96-or-more-of-monolith-soft/


Yea i saw that i don't know whether to laugh or cry (been reading to many Wuxia lately). 

I made a mistake about and didn't check about ownership of monolith (my instinct kept telling me to check but lol).

Honestly tho i just want RPG, good rpgs to sell more so instead of having no wild arm, no suikoden, no lost oddyssey ect.

These type of series will florish and new ones will be made.

But there is going to be a new Wild Arms.... At least in rumor.

http://www.siliconera.com/2014/04/04/new-wild-arms-works-still-far-awaya/

And I have no worries about Xenoblade X turning a profit for Nintendo. 



DavidKell on 14 April 2015
bigtakilla said:
DavidKell said:


Yea i saw that i don't know whether to laugh or cry (been reading to many Wuxia lately). 

I made a mistake about and didn't check about ownership of monolith (my instinct kept telling me to check but lol).

Honestly tho i just want RPG, good rpgs to sell more so instead of having no wild arm, no suikoden, no lost oddyssey ect.

These type of series will florish and new ones will be made.

But there is going to be a new Wild Arms.... At least in rumor.

http://www.siliconera.com/2014/04/04/new-wild-arms-works-still-far-awaya/

And I have no worries about Xenoblade X turning a profit for Nintendo. 

Hopfully true about wild arms.

Profit doesn't worry me as much as nintendo pulling a normal (not enough sells so not worth making more decision).

I would like to see them instead pull a mario and make it a nintendo game (one of the game people conect with nintendo) and bundle it and push it.

And if i buy a wii u then i'd love such a bundle in the USA.



HollyGamer on 14 April 2015
sc94597 said:
Hynad said:

You obviously don't play many JRPGs.

I am well aquainted with the Final Fantasy series, Megami Tensei series, Dragon Quest series, Pokemon series, Tales of series, and plenty of individual JRPG releases (Chrono, Terranigma, Secret of Mana, Rogue Galaxy, The World Ends With You, Lost Odyssey, etc, etc.) I also played Xenogears and Xenosaga I-III before playing Xenoblade. The closest JRPG to Xenoblade is FFXII, but the differences are still way too vast, and while FFXII's reception was poor Xenoblade's was a success. Xenoblade X seems to incorporate even more innovations to the genre. XBC also so happens to be the best acclaimed JRPG in the seventh generation, a generation which represented the decline of the JRPG. What am I missing? 

u miss the fact that nobody has play the game yet, yet you claim this is the best RPG ever made, like the second coming of Jesus bravo, bravo.

Every generation has their own advantage and best game in history for people who enjoy at that time,  people who live now will gladly except this game is the best but not in the future, everything is moving, the future is unpredictible, one prove is if i speak with u in the past u may have an opinion that past JRPG is the best, but who knew that Monolith can come with this good game design.

maybe Square Enix maybe, Bamco, maybe Atlus in the future. So there is "NO GREATEST GAME EVER IN HISTORY" it's all depend on present.



HollyGamer on 14 April 2015
Wyrdness said:
HollyGamer said:
If this game is doing well, i bet another studios will imitate it, there is a lot big publisher especially SE or From Software who will gladly make this kind of game if big company like Microsoft or SONY finance the games development, Square Enix still have the Xenogears IP, and BAMCO still have the Xenoxaga IP, so the future still there for the possibility, but i doubt the XCX will ever be on another platform beside Nintendo. but for another game that will surpass the quality i believe there are a lot of games in the future.

I doubt that tbh, for one this is not an easy game to imitate in everything it does it would not only take a good budget but a competent and consistent team to get anywhere near the quality of the original XC. For reference I played the XV demo and that still has a way to go before it comes close to the original XC's quality based on the demo and that's a game that isn't imitating, the problem with imitation you're treading ground someone has already left their mark on and even being a big publisher SE still has never created such a game like XCX so experience in imitating such a game is another issue.

It's the same reason no imitation has really come close to the GTA games as the developers are merely following R*'s lead.

off course you cannot compare  legendary game like GTA with XCX, XCX is just a baby that need recognition, and need some prove for the test of time and is not yet out so nobody can judge the game yet, But many studio has more reputation more the Monolith soft, so there is a lot of future possibility and nobody knows the future, but the real fact is no game has ever stand the test of time, there might be a nostalgia factor for some games but not for the quality. So claiming this game will not be surpassed with another new game from another studio is very naive.



Around the Network
bigtakilla on 14 April 2015
HollyGamer said:

off course you cannot compare  legendary game like GTA with XCX, XCX is just a baby that need recognition, and need some prove for the test of time and is not yet out so nobody can judge the game yet, But many studio has more reputation more the Monolith soft, so there is a lot of future possibility and nobody knows the future, but the real fact is no game has ever stand the test of time, there might be a nostalgia factor for some games but not for the quality. So claiming this game will not be surpassed with another new game from another studio is very naive.

So there are no great retro games, just naustalgic fans that believe games like Xenoblade, Mario Galaxy, Suikoden II, Final Fantasy VI and VII, Xenogears, Chrono Trigger, Tales Of Symphonia, ect are great in terms of quality on the platform they were created for?

I have never disagreed more with anyone on this forum ever. 

This could be.... Wait for it... The GREATEST DISAGREEMENT IN GAME FORUM HISTORY!



curl-6 on 14 April 2015
Tachikoma said:
When Nintendo tastes a piece of that sweet mobile pie, the profits will taint their once solid stance.
you can more or less bet on it.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't porting XCX to mobile be problematic?



HollyGamer on 14 April 2015
bigtakilla said:
HollyGamer said:

off course you cannot compare  legendary game like GTA with XCX, XCX is just a baby that need recognition, and need some prove for the test of time and is not yet out so nobody can judge the game yet, But many studio has more reputation more the Monolith soft, so there is a lot of future possibility and nobody knows the future, but the real fact is no game has ever stand the test of time, there might be a nostalgia factor for some games but not for the quality. So claiming this game will not be surpassed with another new game from another studio is very naive.

So there are no great retro games, just naustalgic fans that believe games like Xenoblade, Mario Galaxy, Suikoden II, Final Fantasy VI and VII, Xenogears, Chrono Trigger, Tales Of Symphonia, ect are great in terms of quality on the platform they were created for?

I have never disagreed more with anyone on this forum ever. 

This could be.... Wait for it... The GREATEST DISAGREEMENT IN GAME FORUM HISTORY!

read carefully my friend, there is no greatest Game ever that stand in the test of Time, there will be another game that will surpassed every great game in the future that's the rule of thumb of live. The past will just another past and it will be surpassed by a new one.



bigtakilla on 14 April 2015
HollyGamer said:
bigtakilla said:
HollyGamer said:

off course you cannot compare  legendary game like GTA with XCX, XCX is just a baby that need recognition, and need some prove for the test of time and is not yet out so nobody can judge the game yet, But many studio has more reputation more the Monolith soft, so there is a lot of future possibility and nobody knows the future, but the real fact is no game has ever stand the test of time, there might be a nostalgia factor for some games but not for the quality. So claiming this game will not be surpassed with another new game from another studio is very naive.

So there are no great retro games, just naustalgic fans that believe games like Xenoblade, Mario Galaxy, Suikoden II, Final Fantasy VI and VII, Xenogears, Chrono Trigger, Tales Of Symphonia, ect are great in terms of quality on the platform they were created for?

I have never disagreed more with anyone on this forum ever. 

This could be.... Wait for it... The GREATEST DISAGREEMENT IN GAME FORUM HISTORY!

read carefully my friend, there is no greatest Game ever that stand in the test of Time, there will be another game that will surpassed every great game in the future that's the rule of thumb of live. The past will just another past and it will be surpassed by a new one.

But that's not always the case. Someone could go through life believing the original Super Mario Bros is the greatest game of all time. He wouldn't be wrong, as the greatest game of all time is opinion, even when speaking in terms of quality.



Wyrdness on 14 April 2015
HollyGamer said:

off course you cannot compare  legendary game like GTA with XCX, XCX is just a baby that need recognition, and need some prove for the test of time and is not yet out so nobody can judge the game yet, But many studio has more reputation more the Monolith soft, so there is a lot of future possibility and nobody knows the future, but the real fact is no game has ever stand the test of time, there might be a nostalgia factor for some games but not for the quality. So claiming this game will not be surpassed with another new game from another studio is very naive.


Why can't we compare? The point is imitating a design of a great game is not easy so why can't we compare? Fact is many have tried imitating GTA's design and couldn't do it better, XCX is not only regarded as the best JRPG to emerge from last gen even topping long running series like FF, SO, Tales etc... but is also seen as one of the best games from last gen, not an easy feat to imitate. Standing the test of time is how well a game holds up long after release and a number of games with good designs do that well it's not nostalgia. Chrono Trigger, OOT, Metroid Prime, FFVII, DMC3, Ninja Gaiden Black, SF3TS, Smash Bors. Melee etc... these are examples of games that are still fun and enjoyable to play even today long after release and that isn't down to nostalgia either that's a flawed way to think, they stood the test of time simply becaue their designs were really good and stand out even today.

If anything claiming another studio will surpass a game is far more naive as evidence and history has shown imitations rarely ever do so I doubt some imitation of XCX is just going to pop up like you claim.