I really liked the game. The art style was great (I love cellshading!) My only complaints would be that there were not enough dungeons, the quest for the Triforce shards and most of all that freak Tingle who kept asking for all my money!

i wish my friend had as much sense as you guys.

Lol. By the time I got to Tingle, I had damn near maxed out my rupees, and even after paying for all those maps I still had plenty left.

I thought the game was great up to a certain point. The graphics were nice, and the gameplay was classic Zelda. Then I got to the part where I had to find the 8 Triforce pieces. Turned the game off and never finished it. I was so pissed about that part. Give me classic Zelda dungeons, not a treasure hunting game. I was sick of sailing around at that point.

It was a great game, with a good enough story and good gameplay, but the art style bugged me so I just rented the game and did not buy it, I bought phantom hourglass though. . .

I enjoyed it, I really wish there were a few more warp points though since travel towards the end could take an eternity at times

Wind Waker was one of the greatest Zelda games, to me it was short though, I know it had so much to do in it's world which made it great, but I did everything with the minimum hearts, bottles, etc. and finished it fine, it was a lot of fun, the only points I could knock it for was how short it was if you didn't do a lot of side quests and such, and the bosses were easy. But the greatness of the game over shadows the two downers, the style alone is enough for a pickup, but the game has countless other reasons to why you should love it.

Worst 3D Zelda in the past decade. Which really isn't supposed to make the game sound like shit because all the Zelda games have been amazing. I just like the others more :P.

I liked this game but the only thing I didn't like was the long boat travel, other than that it was cool with me.

I loved the art style, my only issue with it was the boat and some camera angles. The rest was all pure awesome! :)