You're not understanding. The vast majority of discussion of The Order has been very negative, a few people hold out hope the game will turn out good yes, but that doesn't make the game overhyped or even hyped at all. 

A WiiU exclusive.

Halo and No Man's Sky. No Man's Sky is going to disappoint and Halo is going to have launch problems, I can see it now.

Zelda and Uncharted are going to be hyped to heaven as well, but those two are going to live up to it.

This is generally speaking, of course.

Is it Mario vs. Donkey Kong? 

The Division. Even tho it's Ubisoft people will be hyping this game up to a maximum and then when the game comes out they'll see a broken mess with a big visual downgrade.

Going by my gut, I would have to say evolve.

I'm surprised more people haven't said Xenoblade...

Don't get me wrong, I'm super hyped for this game...

I just think it's another one of those games that can never live up to the hype it's receiving...

Some games can be incredible and still never love up to hype...

I didn't say it didn't look good. I'm just saying it's overhyped. Other than site-seeing what else is there to do? The novelty will wear off in a couple hours.

What a surprising answer coming from you. ;)

Anyway, I'm going with No Man's Sky. 

Dying light, evolve, splatoon, Bloodborne, NMS, Uncharted 4, Halo 5, Witcher 3, Quantum break, Zelda, The Division, next AC, next COD, among others.