Sticker Star wasn't bad because it had Mario in it.

I know, but with "non-Mario", I.S. has a perfect score

I'm still gonna wait for reviews, general opinions and such first!

What was wrong with it? I haven't played yet

Basically it was stripped. No story, no characters other than Toad clones, combat system oversimplified and battling in general pointless without a leveling system.

Ill play this for sure.

I seriously don't understand how it can look so bad graphically when REvelations exists on the same system.

Sorry but the game is amazing.
For the ones who haven´t played it, play it without excpecting it to be something you want (like the majority here expected it to be TTYD2), just play it and let it surprise you.

It's was advertised as a traditional Paper Mario game, so naturally we're gonna expect it to be one. Even if we remove the Paper Mario name and existence of previous installments, it doesn't change the fact that the game story and gameplay are hollow.

Well i enjoyed those aspects, and correct me if im wrong, but i remember a dedicated portion of E3 dedicated to show how the game was not a traditional Paper Mario. They even explained the stickers mechanics.