3
Super Mario 64
System: Nintendo 64, Nintendo DS
Genre: 3D Platformer
Year: 1997
Rank last year: 3 (=)
Where Yoshi's Island (#4) was the best 2D platformer, Super Mario 64 is the best in the 3D variety, and a monumental game in general. It does everything right and there basically nothing that can be held against it. Nevermind the signifact impact it had on the gaming industry as a whole, it's an amazing game regardless. Still to this day, there's plenty of games that should have looked to Super Mario 64 with better attention when I experience things that are wrong or broken in new games, while this game already did them right almost two decades ago.
It is the definitive Mario experience to me, and one that never failes to impress. The huge variety of levels, all done with amazing design, keep the player entertained from beginning to end. There is no mediocrity here, no lull in creativity. Personally I always enjoyed the slides the most. One of the best things though is, the game's open world-like nature. The Castle hub gives access to each level in a non-linear way, with the only restriction being the Star requirement on certain levels. Super Mario Galaxy (#18) gave us the impression Nintendo hadn't given up on this open style of game-design yet afterall, but like many other fans, I am still waiting for true sequel. A game truly in the philosophy of this game. It's a long wait.