Indeed. Though you're probably thinking of the young, wild west. Red Dead Redemption takes place in a decaying, old age. There's already vehicles, guns that uses clips and some other modern technology. FBI too.

Really? I did not know that. Only played like two hours of it.

Well, you wouldn't know that then :P The first part of the game is a classic old-school wild-west. Once you hit other parts of the world you start noticing how everything has changed.

That really made me want to go back to it for some reason

RDR is for sure one of the best games of last gen.  4th best actually by count of last gen on my top 50. (1 higher that TLoU which I have as 5th best from ps360 era)  Undead Nightmare was absolutely great also.

Yeah, Ive heard pretty much nothing but praise for the game. Im just not big into westerns... I will give it a try again sometime though.

Random guess: Donkey Kong Country.

#28
BioShock (Xbox 360/PC, 2007)
guessed by TruckOSaurus

A spiritual successor to the System Shock games, BioShock honors its predecessors by cleverly merging multiple genres into an amazing game experience. While it's predominantly a first-person shooter, BioShock features elements of adventure games, role-playing games, and even horror games. It's a masterpiece of game design, and it plays very differently depending on the path the player chooses. It's difficult to elaborate on the game without giving away its many secrets, but suffice it to say that Irrational Games, who developed the game, created in BioShock one of the most unique and mesmerizing game settings of all time. From the very first moments of the game to its final frames, BioShock will steal you away to another world.

Nope. What mechanic are you even thinking of anyway? =P

Mine carts.