Maybe to your eyes but not mine. I don't think there is much of a difference. Graphics seems to be a big deal for you but not me. 

There's a lot more going on in new gen version, lighting in areas that are dark, whole new ships, the building on the left of the central building doesn't have neon signs, you can see window panes on the central building on the illuminated parts. It's not a mindblowing difference but the more and more you look the more difference there is.

One is slightly prettier. But still the same game.

Then you are looking through beer goggles. There is a huge difference especially in the amount of stuff going on in the screen.

Well... Like I said before, the difference is noticable but its pretty clear that the difference isnt zomfg worthy

Of course there is a difference, but to be honest i like the "Old Gen" picture more.
I guess actually the "New Gen" picture is meant to look better...^^

But the difference is not nearly anything that I would call generation jump.

It seems people around here either exaggerate (desired platform) or downplay (other platforms) graphics based on their preferences. I know the difference WILL be noticeable IRL (4 player split screen == jaggie's on 360) so I'd rather take the current gen versions. Yes its the "same game" but I'll take the prettier, noticeably less blurry version thanks.

I don't agree with that at least in the case of COD AW. Last gen doesn't look that different to me and many in this thread have said the same thing. 

And that's why we only buy games digitally on PC anymore.

Why the devil do PC games still use DVD!? XD