95+

This is a critical darling to the internet.

89

When does the embargo end? MK8 reviews came two weeks before the release.

84-86

92
And GOTY

93

But over 85 is good enough for me

This is more inline with my opinion than the 80-85 I selected in the poll.  Certainly this game will get an extra 5 pts because it is including the original game.  I could see it brushing with 88-89 for this reason alone if the rest of the game is solid.  I wouldn't be surprised to see this game ultimately hit 92 and end up being a critical darling for the generation.  Whether this will equate to sales is anyone's guess.  It definitely doesn't carry with it the usual Nintendo aesthetic, but the drought we're experiencing might help.

86.

(Even though that seems high.)

Mid 80s IMO.

86

Looks pretty good, so I will go with an 86