http://computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=183358

There is still hope that it will dethrone Ocarina of Time, and become the greatest video game of all time.

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/wii/supersmashbrosbrawl?q=super%20smash%20bros.%20brawl

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/928518.asp 

Okay, but either way, Nintendo still holds the top spot.

Plus I think convincing developers to support the Wii more (since Sonic and Snake are in the game) would be a greater accomplishment for the game.

I'm sure people will come in and blast the site.  But after reading the review, I think they have reasonable gripes.  More so with Nintendo games in general, but still gripes.  And a 9.3 is an excellent score still for a subjective rating.

ngamer also gave it 93%.. i'm not sure who was expecting this to get as high a score as galaxy, when people still doubted galaxy's current status after like 10 100%s in a row

Brawl is still ranked #1 on GameRankings, but it's no longer ranked #1 on Metacritic. As long as more 100% reviews come in, then Brawl will have a great chance of becoming of topping all of the charts. Just because Sonic and Snake are in the game, wont make it better. Besides, do we really care for Sonic anymore? He's been in more bad games, then good games. He sucked, ever since Heroes.

Also? What do you mean, "also?" It "is" the one that gave it 93%. Currently, it is still ranked, higher then Galaxy, and even Ocarina, on Game rankings, so it might keep the crown. It's far too early to tell, since its score is averaged from only three reviews on Game Rankings, and four, on Metacritic. It's a shame that it's no longer #1 on Metacritic, though. Ocarina has a score of 99 on Metacritic, Brawl has 98, and Galaxy has 97.

I don't think anybody was seriously expecting the game to stay at 100% forever, although it would've been nice if it would've displayed on the sites as such for even a few days.

This has already been posted in the official one. Why do you think they created an official one? Take it in it!

charaters arent different enough? what do they expect when you have 35! Looks to me like they were nitpicking. Where did they talk about the fun factor?

"And there's an undeniable thrill from seeing these Nintendo legends interact in this bizarre manner - though this is a tad undermined when the true hero of the piece is revealed to be of non-Nintendo origins."

Ah, spoilers... gotta love 'em.