LemonSlice said:
binary solo said:
Except it is. See above definition. If you don't like it take it up with the dictionary people.
|
I just checked the Oxford Dictionary of English, Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary, Encyclopedia Brittanica and World Book Encyclopedia. None of them say that chess is a sport.
|
Merriam-Webster's definition of sport encompasses chess: 1.a : a source of diversion : recreation. And: to amuse oneself. Even the summary definition can encompass chess: "a contest or game in which people do certain physical activities according to a specific set of rules and compete against each other." Chess and video games involve physical activity, just not very strenuous physical activity.
Collins Dictionary says sport is an activity for "pleasure, competition OR excercise" excercise is one of the options for sport but not a solely defining characteristic. So chess and video games are in here.
Oxford dictionary you have more ground, it's definition indicates physical exertion. So it's a very narrow definition compared to the other sources. Though it also undermines the physical exertion aspect by saying fishing is a sport. Some fishing involves physical exertion, but a lot of fishing doesn't, so there's some possible wriggle room even here.
So you can go with that one definition if you want, but I'm going with the majority view from all those various sources. Dictionary.com uses the Collins definition as well as the Random House dictionary, so it counts as 2 sources. So 4 dictionaries out of 5 encompass competetive activities that do not invole physical exertion within the scope of their definition of sport. Therefore eSports and chess are sports acording to the clear majority view of dictionaries cited herein.
You don't go to encyclopedias to get the definition of a word, you use dictionaries for that. But if you want to get all encyclopediary on it lets' check Wikipedia too. It says that the IOC recognises Chess and Bridge (the card game) as sports. But don't let Wikipedia put you off, go to the source http://www.arisf.org/members which is the IOC recognised sports federations website. If the IOC says Chess and Bridge are sports, who are you to say otherwise?
Also for another reference, and possibly for the true international consensus on sport you should check out SportAccord http://www.sportaccord.com/en/index.php
So really the weight of definition is against you when it comes to chess. And I think it is only a matter of time before eSports gets admitted into SportAccord. SportAccords criteria does say that "Applications from sports with limited physical or atheletic activity will be carefully considered." Does mean eSports has to prove itself more than physically demanding activities. But there is precedent there already given acceptance of sports that involve less phycial activity than gaming. Darts is also there, as well as billiards.
So prety much the no voters don;t have a leg to stand on when you look at all the objective information out there which defines what is and isn't a sport.
Opinions are like arseholes, everyone's got one. Which is why on these topics the opinions of forum dwellers are worth exactly nothing in the face of actual objective consensus definitions, which exist and are easy to find.
Here endeth the lesson.