By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

WhiteEaglePL said:
Wright, I don't buy it


What possible reason would I have for making such a lie? Especially when I'm just a few HP left to die?



Around the Network
Wright said:
theprof00 said:
Wright, why would you scan eric when I told padib to kill eric?
That would've been a completely wasted scan.

Also,
I asked earlier for some information, but I'm sure you haven't been able to read up yet. Here is the question again.
"Wright,
Early in the game you talked about the nuker a lot.
later on this would be addressed and the reasoning would be that you're the ghost finding role.
How is it that you would know that?

Second,
How does your role work?

Third,
When you scanned padib, what was the result? I know you've answered this before. Could you elucidate a bit?"


Lastly, why did you scan trucks night one? Why did you pick him?


Wasn't padib going to kill me? I already had suspicious of EricFabian. We never agreed on a plan of who scans who - especially when you choose to end Day 3 abruptly after I told you to wait. In fact, I didn't know you wanted me to scan any of those two.

 

Regarding your questions:

 

I asked WoW what my PM role was about, because I had doubts. He replied back, and so I learned that my objective was to find the nuker. From there on, I started talking about nukes, as I already told padib once. It made me get suspicious of EricFabian, since he was surprised with the trivia he gave me.

 

My role works like I already explained you: Each night, I might choose a player. (Paraphrasing is okay at this point in the game?) It will enable me to see if the chosen character is using a personal cloaking device.

 

I told WoW that I would be using Detector on Padib. His reply (same as TruckOSaurus and EricFabian's) was something along the lines of "The Detector doesn't get any response. This person is not using a cloaking device."

 

I picked Trucks first day because he said something that completely surprised me: claiming that he would be killed, and that he wanted the Medic's blessing all for himself. I thought "maybe he claims so because he's the nuker and wants protection".

Your story holds up. I saw your post about this on day 1 and thought you might go after trucks.

Why didn't you go after eric on day one when you made such a stink about him being the nuke? Did trucks comment really throw you off that much?
What about padib? Why did you choose him?



theprof00 said:

Your story holds up. I saw your post about this on day 1 and thought you might go after trucks.

Why didn't you go after eric on day one when you made such a stink about him being the nuke? Did trucks comment really throw you off that much?
What about padib? Why did you choose him?


Because, again, someone (padib) made a comment that really threw me off: that the was able to survive the nuke blast.



theprof00 said:
According to the meta, I believe this is the setup.
Padib- third party survivor/rogue town
unknown? -third party assistant
Nuker?- third party SK
Mafia godfather

Last 1 or 2 mafia is possibly either the shield marines, or the stim marines, using their vetting process as a means of hiding themselves.
There is also the possibility that mafia have a role cop, which would have given them all the information regarding those players.
IE; someone scans white, sees he has hitpoints a,b,c etc. Pretends to have the same.
Could someone look through the vetting processes and see who brings up stats and testing other players etc? Like, does someone say "can you test me" or whatever. Also, it would be good to know who claimed which roles and when. If WEPL claimed shield marine day 1, then he can likely be one of the trusted claims.

I know there's a lot of people jsut sitting around waiting here, so please feel free to look this stuff up.
Thanks.


from memory:


The second confirmed stim marine was Radish who asked to be confirmed by Trucks. He was asked about the percentage of hp lost when using stim and replied very quickly with the right number



Wright, I'm pretty sure that anyone who is alive right now expected you to target khan or imp.
You would be the only person here to think that "the plan" wasn't in effect.

Especially when IT WAS PART OF THE FREAKING FLAVOR.

ANyway, whatever. Won't be the last time a nub fucks up.
(I'm glad you scanned eric for the record. It just makes me more suspicious of you unfortunately that you ignored orders)

PS: I ended the day because it was imperative to get spurge to stop talking. He was sending people all over the place, and would've faked any evidence he could. Remember, he said that the mafia team scanned you and got "a hazy response". I know that I appeared to take too much control, but trust me, it was for the good of the town and sanity.



Around the Network
theprof00 said:
According to the meta, I believe this is the setup.
Padib- third party survivor/rogue town
unknown? -third party assistant
Nuker?- third party SK
Mafia godfather

Last 1 or 2 mafia is possibly either the shield marines, or the stim marines, using their vetting process as a means of hiding themselves.
There is also the possibility that mafia have a role cop, which would have given them all the information regarding those players.
IE; someone scans white, sees he has hitpoints a,b,c etc. Pretends to have the same.
Could someone look through the vetting processes and see who brings up stats and testing other players etc? Like, does someone say "can you test me" or whatever. Also, it would be good to know who claimed which roles and when. If WEPL claimed shield marine day 1, then he can likely be one of the trusted claims.

I know there's a lot of people jsut sitting around waiting here, so please feel free to look this stuff up.
Thanks.


IIRC, Imp and Wonk both claimed vanilla Marine after the first 2 marine kills, so that should be noted down.

Both had shady play in the first 2 Days also, and they were backing eachother up on some stuff (The Imp "trap"?). I need to have a re-read and make sure I have my mental notes right.



                            

Mr Khan and WhiteEagle used each other to confirm their claims as well, but that situation is much more bungled with White first claiming but not saying much about it, then Khan claiming and White saying that was the same ability as his. I'll see if I can find the time to find the whole interaction if no one else wants to dig it up, but that chain of events is all over the place



theprof00 said:
Wright, I'm pretty sure that anyone who is alive right now expected you to target khan or imp.
You would be the only person here to think that "the plan" wasn't in effect.

Especially when IT WAS PART OF THE FREAKING FLAVOR.

ANyway, whatever. Won't be the last time a nub fucks up.
(I'm glad you scanned eric for the record. It just makes me more suspicious of you unfortunately that you ignored orders)

PS: I ended the day because it was imperative to get spurge to stop talking. He was sending people all over the place, and would've faked any evidence he could. Remember, he said that the mafia team scanned you and got "a hazy response". I know that I appeared to take too much control, but trust me, it was for the good of the town and sanity.

 

But I told you to wait. Night 3 just got too damn fucking early. And I don't recall anywhere that you told me to scan imp or khan! (maybe I'm mistaken, but still)



Id be more willing to believe the Shield Marine story than the Stim Marine story by the way.

WEPL was solid on his story from early on.



                            

theprof00 said:
According to the meta, I believe this is the setup.
Padib- third party survivor/rogue town
unknown? -third party assistant
Nuker?- third party SK
Mafia godfather

Last 1 or 2 mafia is possibly either the shield marines, or the stim marines, using their vetting process as a means of hiding themselves.
There is also the possibility that mafia have a role cop, which would have given them all the information regarding those players.
IE; someone scans white, sees he has hitpoints a,b,c etc. Pretends to have the same.
Could someone look through the vetting processes and see who brings up stats and testing other players etc? Like, does someone say "can you test me" or whatever. Also, it would be good to know who claimed which roles and when. If WEPL claimed shield marine day 1, then he can likely be one of the trusted claims.

I know there's a lot of people jsut sitting around waiting here, so please feel free to look this stuff up.
Thanks.

Gosh.....now I don't feel like I can trust Khan entirely.