By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Conegamer said:
Wonktonodi said:
Conegamer said:
Wonktonodi said:
@Ryan what's the benefit to not fully claiming now when you're implying a scan? Also do you think he's the nuke?

@cone, I think you just missed a big update

I disagree. I'm not saying my opinion on who is or isn't Mafia; that's not the focus right now. There's just something which unsettles me about Spurge, and if he honestly does have the ability to scan people; why waste it scanning me when it'd be the last chance to do so? It all seems like stalling to get over the finish line to me; same with padib. Both of these concern me greatly indeed.

because why would your ability be town?

Why wouldn't my ability be town? Why would there be a Protoss Reaper? Why would I need to avoid attacks if I can attack myself and won't be under fire?


Sorry wrong question, if Ryan scanned prof as scum, wouldn't that make your whole claim very suspect, since profs the one who voted you for not seeing you and leading to your claim. Though that would be more if he thinks your mafia than the nuker



Around the Network
Wonktonodi said:

Sorry wrong question, if Ryan scanned prof as scum, wouldn't that make your whole claim very suspect, since profs the one who voted you for not seeing you and leading to your claim. Though that would be more if he thinks your mafia than the nuker

I see where you're coming from but I feel I may have answered the question in my above post.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Cone you are making sense.
Spurge and padib not so much.

Spurge, I sincerely doubt you have a zerg scan on me. That is ridiculous. You're just trying to pull a prof or hatmoza and pretending to be something to back up your suspicions.



Padib, serious question:
Why are you waiting on people to make a good guess? So you can see who's smart?



(3) EricFabian - theprof00, Wonktonodi, padib
(1) impertinence - WhiteEaglePL
(1) spurgeonryan - ConeGamer
(1) theprof00 - spurgeonryan
(1) Wright - Mr Khan

(6) Not Voting - Carl2291, EricFabian, impertinence, radishhead, TruckOSaurus, Wright,

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Countdown to Night 3: http://itsalmo.st/#night3

Please PM Words of Wisdom or myself if there's an issue with the vote count.



Around the Network

haha this is great!
People think I'm mafia and still won't lynch me. epic!



spurgeonryan said:
So... you ( wonk) just want to waste what I said and jump after some random person we want to think is the nuker?

You think Wright is so stupid he would just come into this thread and talk about nukes. Padib said his ability happenes tonight right? Yet another person who if he is lying, can be lynched tomorrow.

Eric is quiet and a newb...that makes him the nukeer?

Radish is not playing like radish....where is our evidence?

Imp....he has gone full force into this thread and we are just supposed to suspect he is the nuker? Can we really just lynch random people and hope for the best? Is that how we should play? If so, then why all the convesation ? Why stop the sparks lynch to talk if we are just going after random people?

I am telling "you", and you know this to be true. If I say anything about myself I will be jumped on. Like a horse on a fat juicy carrot. Tomorrow you will fully understand why.

So what? What is your suggestion for us today? iny, miny, miny, moe? Can we trust you?Or are you just protecting theprof?

If someone has some real evidence for who the nuker is then by all means ...lets go! We will lynch him and then theprof tomorrow.

Anyone? Our time is running out, can't keep quiet for too long about your roles.

I will wait.

you talk so much but say so little.

how is not lynching today wasting what you said? What you want to do is waste a day on the least/unconfirmed. It's a bad strategy. Actually saying to little will get you jumped on. I was lynched as a doctor once for just saying I had a power role and not what it was.

When you say as much as you have, your reasons for holding back make you more suspect. People already think you could be the nuke.

the evidence on Radish is his ties to TOS.

you're straw man argument is frustrating. We talk to eliminate those we can eliminate and come up with whats best.

remember from everyone elses perspective, we are all asking why should we trust your claim?

If your theory for not trusting me is that I'm protecting the prof, that I'm protss or that I'm town, I don't really care. Think about the logic. It's not someone at random. It's about probabilties from actions, activity interations and claims.

you're saying time is running out, doesn't help town, just makes you seem panicked, it also seems fake when you want to lynch someone today who you claim to know if scum but not the nuke. Then we'd REALLY be running out of time



Conegamer said:
Wonktonodi said:

Sorry wrong question, if Ryan scanned prof as scum, wouldn't that make your whole claim very suspect, since profs the one who voted you for not seeing you and leading to your claim. Though that would be more if he thinks your mafia than the nuker

I see where you're coming from but I feel I may have answered the question in my above post.

untill we know what spurge can scan, (if anything) luking for the nuke might not be possible with his abilities. Though I do agree he should target someone other than you. Though it would be nice to have confirmation on you. If his claim was right on prof you'd be dead anyway.



Here's a fun argument regarding why I'm still alive.
As town, I've only been lynched once in 30+ games.

I haven't been lynched. Therefore I must be town. :D



Who are think are possible Nukers: Wonk, Imp, Eric , Spurge.


Padib will join that list if no Protoss is harmed toNight.