By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

Conegamer on 23 September 2014
TruckOSaurus said:
I believe Wright 100% so I also believe his results which clear padib of at least being a Ghost.

So are you thinking of either Spurge or Eric then? Or someone different entirely?



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Around the Network
WhiteEaglePL on 23 September 2014

My vote remains on Impertinance. I think he is the Nuker, but to be sure someone needs to scan him or something. I think he is just trying to blend in.

@Mr Khan DONT quote, but I think these vague clues will help me decide once and for all if your telling the truth. Is you defence stat a odd, or even number? Is it very very very high, or not much above the usual 0? And finally, is it a 1 digit number?

I'm asking since you asked someone to get me ask you somehow....

@TOS , why do you believe Wright 100%? So far the people that I don't trust are Wright, Eric,Prof, Imp and Spurge.



Smeags on 23 September 2014

(3) EricFabian - theprof00, Wonktonodi, padib
(1) impertinence - WhiteEaglePL
(1) spurgeonryan - ConeGamer
(1) theprof00 - spurgeonryan
(1) Wright - Mr Khan

(6) Not Voting - Carl2291, EricFabian, impertinence, radishhead, TruckOSaurus, Wright,

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Countdown to Night 3: http://itsalmo.st/#night3

Please PM Words of Wisdom or myself if there's an issue with the vote count.



3DS Rec Thread ~ Wii U Rec Thread ~ Xbox One Rec Thread

Wonktonodi on 23 September 2014
Conegamer said:
Wonktonodi said:
@Ryan what's the benefit to not fully claiming now when you're implying a scan? Also do you think he's the nuke?

@cone, I think you just missed a big update

I disagree. I'm not saying my opinion on who is or isn't Mafia; that's not the focus right now. There's just something which unsettles me about Spurge, and if he honestly does have the ability to scan people; why waste it scanning me when it'd be the last chance to do so? It all seems like stalling to get over the finish line to me; same with padib. Both of these concern me greatly indeed.

because why would your ability be town?



Conegamer on 23 September 2014

My big problem is that you're trying to scan me when I've already been scanned. By all means do so if you want, but it would be a waste on what will be the last chance to find the nuke when I've already been scanned by theprof (who even if he is Mafia wouldn't lie, and that's all I'm considering right now. I think theprof is Mafia but there's bigger targets right now). Combined with the evasive play and the stall tactics (IMO) it all seems rather suspicious, is all.

It's not a revenge vote, I was writing it beforehand and was about to submit when I saw your post and made an addendum. Had you said nothing, it would have made no difference.

I need to head out, but I'll post more later. If you are town, or not the nuker, however, then do what you must. But if your ability is the one to find the nuker then there's better targets. Seems like your decision has already been made though.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Around the Network
Conegamer on 23 September 2014
Wonktonodi said:
Conegamer said:
Wonktonodi said:
@Ryan what's the benefit to not fully claiming now when you're implying a scan? Also do you think he's the nuke?

@cone, I think you just missed a big update

I disagree. I'm not saying my opinion on who is or isn't Mafia; that's not the focus right now. There's just something which unsettles me about Spurge, and if he honestly does have the ability to scan people; why waste it scanning me when it'd be the last chance to do so? It all seems like stalling to get over the finish line to me; same with padib. Both of these concern me greatly indeed.

because why would your ability be town?

Why wouldn't my ability be town? Why would there be a Protoss Reaper? Why would I need to avoid attacks if I can attack myself and won't be under fire?



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Wonktonodi on 23 September 2014
spurgeonryan said:
So.....then what should I do coneyG? Just not do anything? is that what you want?

I have thought you could be thenuker from the beginning. I have said it before as well.

@ wonk

We have had a whole two days of people copying off other roles. You know as well as I that theprof is not a newb at this. I think you vets can probably figure it out without me saying any more anyways. But if I just up and say it, his teamates ..who knows if they are newbs or not will then have a better grasp of what to deal with.

@ Cone
Classic revenge vote. Lol. You all of a sudden got super involved once I jumped on your buddy theprof. Or you are scared that I am going to catch you tonight. Nuker or scum you are.

I have been participating the whole game. Basically those who doubt me are saying I am either nuker. Not likely because I requested to be lynched tomorrow if I turn out to be lying, and tonight when I am killed by one of scum that will also prove I am no nuker.

Basically this is how I see it. Two games ago I could not even take a piss without playing poorly. The only time I was actually a decent player was as town. I once made trucks leave the game because I played so poorly, theprof refuseed to talk with me IRL for a year and did not even contact me when I hosted a game. I was a horrible player, and you all think I can be a nuker or scum and all of a sudden be a great player in one game?

Lol..IMP I think you need to give these guys another logic lesson, because that is illogical. The only logical explaination is that I am sincer and telling the truth. I voted and never took my vote off sparks. I was wrong about nicks, but never argued against astro either. I was wrong like many others. So now I am supposedly going after protoss, and zerg and somehow am a nuker as well?

And coneyG instantly revenge votes me. Now I know I have your attention ConeyG. Do you not know what a revenge vote is? It is what a scared scum does when he feels threatened. I have seen it time and time again.

any other questions? Besides from theprof who will just turn and twist it around like he does with padib for pages on end. Like he has already started to do today. Trucks even had to jump in and stop it.

@coneyG

Does anyone else have my ability or am I your only hope in finding the nuker. Now you want to lynch me?

Nuker right there boys! I could vote either of them today, but since I have proof on prof I think that is the safe lynch.

Any other questions? Wonk? Feel free. I will answer what I feel safe to answer. But again. I am not going to argue flavor with carl, have people parroting me, etc. That just causes more confusion. I showed why theprof is scum even without telling you all I checked into him. Then I told you I checked in to him.

theprof misses nothing, yet he ignored my little hints I threw out in my 2-4 posts before today? I even asked him what he thought about zergs and he ignored me. Fancy that!

look into those copied roles. khan said he had whites, white tested him,

Radish said his sounded like TOS, TOS tested him.

So your responce is to say little so that you can't test or be tested? We could potentially figure it out, or you could be trying to claim small to sneak by. Lynching prof wouldn't be a good test for today. Since he was already suspect by many players but as scum and not the nuke so we'd on'y have one left for the nuke. Lynching you today wouldn't be a good test for the day either, we have two lynches to find the nuke, I'm all for checking the claimed power second, gives you in theory more time to scan, and scum a night where they have potenially another questionmark to target.



WhiteEaglePL on 23 September 2014
spurgeonryan said:
WhiteEaglePL said:
My vote remains on Impertinance. I think he is the Nuker, but to be sure someone needs to scan him or something. I think he is just trying to blend in.

@Mr Khan DONT quote, but I think these vague clues will help me decide once and for all if your telling the truth. Is you defence stat a odd, or even number? Is it very very very high, or not much above the usual 0? And finally, is it a 1 digit number?

I'm asking since you asked someone to get me ask you somehow....

@TOS , why do you believe Wright 100%? So far the people that I don't trust are Wright, Eric,Prof, Imp and Spurge.


You are going to waste a vote on impertinence just because you think he is the nuker?

 

What have I said at all this game to make you not trust me? I have scum hunted and even helped lynch scum. As we have seen, scum hides in the sidelines. You are saying I have risked coming out, and made a much less crazy claim than padib has and now I am not trustworthy? What else do I have to do?

I told you guys theprof is zerg. What else can I say? We have already seen people fighting over the dumbest things. You know this the most since your partial claim yesterday when people jumped on you.

 

If I am supposedly the nuker, then you guys can lynch me tomorrow. Nuke threat gone. So I do not see the problem here. IF I am lying about theprof you will see at the end of the day, then you can make all your choices tomorrow. As i said, scum will probably kill me tonight anyways now that they know I have power and they are at risk. So it is win win for us all I think. Even if we find the nuke, we still need to lynch scum. Right or wrong?


I don't see the evidence of how Prof is Zerg....or if Zerg are even in this game. But how will we see if Prof is Zerg at end of the day? What will be the proof from you? Because I don't accept just saying he is....

 

Also, I didn't say your the nuker lol. I think these are nukers in terms of order that I think most:
1.Imp

2. Wonk.

3. Padib



WhiteEaglePL on 23 September 2014
Wonktonodi said:
spurgeonryan said:
So.....then what should I do coneyG? Just not do anything? is that what you want?

I have thought you could be thenuker from the beginning. I have said it before as well.

@ wonk

We have had a whole two days of people copying off other roles. You know as well as I that theprof is not a newb at this. I think you vets can probably figure it out without me saying any more anyways. But if I just up and say it, his teamates ..who knows if they are newbs or not will then have a better grasp of what to deal with.

@ Cone
Classic revenge vote. Lol. You all of a sudden got super involved once I jumped on your buddy theprof. Or you are scared that I am going to catch you tonight. Nuker or scum you are.

I have been participating the whole game. Basically those who doubt me are saying I am either nuker. Not likely because I requested to be lynched tomorrow if I turn out to be lying, and tonight when I am killed by one of scum that will also prove I am no nuker.

Basically this is how I see it. Two games ago I could not even take a piss without playing poorly. The only time I was actually a decent player was as town. I once made trucks leave the game because I played so poorly, theprof refuseed to talk with me IRL for a year and did not even contact me when I hosted a game. I was a horrible player, and you all think I can be a nuker or scum and all of a sudden be a great player in one game?

Lol..IMP I think you need to give these guys another logic lesson, because that is illogical. The only logical explaination is that I am sincer and telling the truth. I voted and never took my vote off sparks. I was wrong about nicks, but never argued against astro either. I was wrong like many others. So now I am supposedly going after protoss, and zerg and somehow am a nuker as well?

And coneyG instantly revenge votes me. Now I know I have your attention ConeyG. Do you not know what a revenge vote is? It is what a scared scum does when he feels threatened. I have seen it time and time again.

any other questions? Besides from theprof who will just turn and twist it around like he does with padib for pages on end. Like he has already started to do today. Trucks even had to jump in and stop it.

@coneyG

Does anyone else have my ability or am I your only hope in finding the nuker. Now you want to lynch me?

Nuker right there boys! I could vote either of them today, but since I have proof on prof I think that is the safe lynch.

Any other questions? Wonk? Feel free. I will answer what I feel safe to answer. But again. I am not going to argue flavor with carl, have people parroting me, etc. That just causes more confusion. I showed why theprof is scum even without telling you all I checked into him. Then I told you I checked in to him.

theprof misses nothing, yet he ignored my little hints I threw out in my 2-4 posts before today? I even asked him what he thought about zergs and he ignored me. Fancy that!

look into those copied roles. khan said he had whites, white tested him,

Radish said his sounded like TOS, TOS tested him.

So your responce is to say little so that you can't test or be tested? We could potentially figure it out, or you could be trying to claim small to sneak by. Lynching prof wouldn't be a good test for today. Since he was already suspect by many players but as scum and not the nuke so we'd on'y have one left for the nuke. Lynching you today wouldn't be a good test for the day either, we have two lynches to find the nuke, I'm all for checking the claimed power second, gives you in theory more time to scan, and scum a night where they have potenially another questionmark to target.

The test is in progress.....



Conegamer on 23 September 2014
spurgeonryan said:
Again ConeyG... Who should I scan? Should I let a pack of wild dogs dictate what I do? Why don't you tell me who to scan so that scum knows it as well. Why is it so bad that I suspect you? You have been mia half the game other than when it suits you, and now we should just jump out and trust you? Why are you any different than anyone else? Why should I just ignore you and check into someone else?

does that make sense?

There's several good targets, but at the end of the day it's your vote. I would perhaps suggest either EricFabian or Radish however.

You're making sense, don't worry. I just went with my gut instinct; which I'm happy to admit might be incorrect. 

@padib What I meant was regardless if TheProf is Mafia, he would still be looking for the nuker same as anyone else. So if he honestly thought I was the ghost after scanning him, and what he says lined up with what I did last night, then there's no reason for me to believe he's lying about being able to scan. It far from proves his innocence, however. If anything it merely confirms it if Wright is telling the truth as well, but that's something for another time. Right now we all need to look for this nuker; that should be a priority. I'm just considering all the angles and trying to do my own thing after people said yesterday that I was merely bandwagoning. I might not be very good at it; but it's worth a try.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.