Im not. Im just playing the game he proposed.
the rule was to say definitely who. I cant participate unless I say its spurge definitely.
but I might be thinking eric as well.
cant decide which.


Im not. Im just playing the game he proposed.
the rule was to say definitely who. I cant participate unless I say its spurge definitely.
but I might be thinking eric as well.
cant decide which.


Actually, based on who padib went after today im gunna say the nuker is definitely eric.


TruckOSaurus said:
We don't have many chances at this though. What you propose is possible but far from probable so for the time being I'm going to leave out Khan, White and radish out of the list of possible Nukers. |
Presuming that we used percentages just as you and radish did.

Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.


Mr Khan said:
Presuming that we used percentages just as you and radish did. |
Should be alright then.
Signature goes here!
spurgeonryan said:
Lol. The webs you weave prof. You said it yourself..."I am back ....wouldn't you say spurge?" Or something to that effect. You most certainly are. Too bad you are on the wrong side this time. |
lol im not weaving any webs.
I'm not even sure what your case is against me.
Is it that I'm alive? Maybe scum got nervous that I would be protected so I am being left alone? And people aren't supposed to be informed when they are visited or anything. How does me being alive mean I'm scum? Need I remind you that last game I was alive (because of you) and left alive the rest of the game and I wasn't scum. Not trying to bring up past games, but being alive is not a scumtell.
I'm back from vacation and now I'm super active. This is a point against me how? Because I'm contributing? I agree that I would gamble on padib, but let's not pretend like Padib is the most trustworthy of people right now. He's confirmed third party who wins even if the town loses. Dude should be lynched at first possible chance because he has just as much reason to hurt us as he does to help us. Need I remind you that he wins even if the nuke goes off. We have no reason to trust him, he'll just run us around in circles. Maybe it's Padib who is arguing for the sake of looking town. Last game I called him town for being hardheaded and wrong. Maybe it's him who is doing what you say?
I've been arguing with Padib because he's an anti-town. He claims to be second party town, but he's not. A townie loses if town loses. A survivor (an example of another third party) is not a townie, he only has some vague motivation to act like a townie.
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Survivor
"Survivors are traditionally considered anti-Town and thus premium lynch targets. In truth, whether a Survivor is a burden to the Town is up to the Survivor's mentality. The Survivor can't be too much of a help to the Town or else they will get killed at Night; they can't be too much of a burden to Town or they will get lynched for sanity's sake. Thus, playing as Survivor requires the player to pace themselves. "
And he's pushing me to claim. Why is this not a problem for anyone?
I don't want to go after you, but we need to find the nuke. Both myself and wright have cleared six people in total (including ourselves). That leaves 6 potential players as nuke. 3 of those have claimed. The remaining three are yourself(spurge), impertinence, and eric. Regardless of whether or not I'm parroting what other people are saying, this is the correct way to find the nuke. This is mafia 101; deduction. If everyone else CAN'T be the nuke, then one of you three are.


| spurgeonryan said:
Lol. The webs you weave prof. You said it yourself..."I am back ....wouldn't you say spurge?" Or something to that effect. You most certainly are. Too bad you are on the wrong side this time. |
Lol, I love your style of speech spurge, but you are wrong on this.


So, I'll just drop by and say something about whom I think the "ghost" could be. This won't have any in-depth analysis, just feeling and opinion from what I've seen thus far.
The following people could be this "ghost" character; I am removing the characters whom have claimed from this last for now, or those of whom I am getting a strong read from either way. I am however going to be including padib; for reasons I shall explain further down.
Carl (Was scanned and not revealed to be a ghost)
Cone (Was scanned, claimed to use "jetpack")
Eric
Imp
Khan (Is a shield marine, apparently)
Padib
Radish
Spurge
TheProf (Does not appear to be the ghost; however his methods make me suspicious for other reasons, the priority right now is not on pushing TheProf IMO)
Trucks (Was scanned)
WEPL (Is a shield marine, apparently)
Wonk
Wright
So who's left? Eric, Impertinance, Padib, Radish, Spurge, Wonk and Wright.
Whilst I'm not 100% sure about the whole Trucks and Radish exchange, it does at least suggest he's not the nuker. We must, ofcourse, consider the fact that said "nuker" could have a regular role and a secondary role of nuker. It is unlikely, but not considering all possibilities could be an error. Similarly he hasn't voted yet. Perhaps; the nuker is unable to vote? Or is that too much of a strecth?
Wonk to me seems too...suspicious to be the ghost if that makes sense. I certainly wouldn't be surprised if he transpires to be Mafia but that can wait another day.
Impertinance (to answer your question also, I'm a reaper which I have already mentioned) confuses me, but I think that's just his style. I would like to hear a little more from him but I'm willing to focus on other targets for now. There's more pressing matters to attend to and this is something we cannot forget.
This leaves us with EricFabian, padib, Spurge and Wright. I'll go into them a little more, now.
EricFabian - My opinions on Eric are well known. He's detrimental to town, if he is town, and he hasn't really been contributing. I don't feel like he's Mafia because they wouldn't let him play like this. They'd have told him to post more, and more consistently. Similarly however, he's not really contributing overly to assisting town, which again bothers me. The number of times I, and others, have advised him to contribute more and the number of times he's promised to share his more in-depth thoughts is worryingly high, and yet there's still no real signs of activity. Is he hiding in the shadows as he is the nuker? I'm not sure, but he's worth considering.
padib - I'm not here to claim what he's shared so far is incorrect. My concern is he's almost "stringing people along" and this latest move about revealing whom the ghost is is most concerning. Let's consider one possibility for now. Let's say padib claims I'm the ghost. I get lynched, flip Reaper and then people realize padib was lying. Obviously he'd be the target for the next day, but what if he has protection for one day from a lynch too? He survives, turns out he's the nuke and he wins because we're putting too much trust in him.
There's just...something that unsettles me about him. Why does he have so many powers, so much protection? Looking through his exchanges concerns me and he should not be ignored.
Wright - From the get go Wright has been my main suspect, from the PM debacle to the pushing for nuke questions etc., but today I'm not so sure. He claims to be a scientist, in space, which would explain his PM debacle and he could honestly just be overenthusiastic about the whole thing. I'm willing to trust Wright, to an extent. His claim seems to be solid and hasn't been counter-claimed yet, and it follows the lore of the series nicely too. There's either been a lot of work put into a false claim, or he is honestly telling the truth. For now, I'm willing to believe the latter but I'm not overly sure. Suspicion doesn't just disappear!
So, that leaves Spurgeonryan, and he is my suspect for the bomber. Very evasive and non-commital, some shady play and this latest claim to scan me seems like a waste of time. Scanning one of the above three, or even Radish, would be a better use of time if he can scan (particularly as I was scanned by theProf last night, if he is to be believed. But I do, because it all aligns well) if you ask me. Spurge has yet to do anything to convince me he isn't the bomb, which the above three have to an extent at least. Lots of "wait until tomorrow" and other delay tactics. I'd like to hear why you aren't this nuker, Spurge. But until then;
Vote - Spurgeonryan
@Ryan what's the benefit to not fully claiming now when you're implying a scan? Also do you think he's the nuke?
@cone, I think you just missed a big update
| Wonktonodi said: @Ryan what's the benefit to not fully claiming now when you're implying a scan? Also do you think he's the nuke? @cone, I think you just missed a big update |
I disagree. I'm not saying my opinion on who is or isn't Mafia; that's not the focus right now. There's just something which unsettles me about Spurge, and if he honestly does have the ability to scan people; why waste it scanning me when it'd be the last chance to do so? It all seems like stalling to get over the finish line to me; same with padib. Both of these concern me greatly indeed.


I believe Wright 100% so I also believe his results which clear padib of at least being a Ghost.
Signature goes here!