and then silence....

first imps vote seems way out of place, since white talked of his role long before kahn was in the game. kahn mentions that he thinks he has the same role. Even confirmed the extra defense, before whites question.

So what was taken as role hunting, I saw as him trying to make sure that kahn isn't just saying the same role, but has something more to back it up.

so HOS on imp

Carl though is something else. He can make decent case with the words that white has used, but between how he did that yesterday with Nick, and his putting sparks at L1 so early, I don't see that my vote can be anywhere else.

Unvote
Vote Carl

I see several

I love seeing this post! I jumped on the WhiteEagle claim to see if I could get scum to band in on trying to vote him. I did not actually think White was trying to out a doc, but framed it to see if a train would form on that accusation.

Great was my delight when one of my prime suspects jumped out of the woodwork almost immidiately. I was hoping to let this trap sit a little longer, but I guess one scum is better than none, right?

Mega HoS on Carl

Unvote

223 posts to read, gimme a sec, I'll make a big post with quotes and stuff

don't thank him for finally posting

be furious at him for taking so long :P

Seems like times a changing, Carl. Perhaps now would be a good time to perhaps answer some of the questions posed to you, and yes, that might involve revealing your role. 

Also glad to see you back Radish. Looking forward to the input!

And Spurge, might I ask who in your opinion is the bomber? I've had a quick look through but can't see your opinions on it anywhere.

But something somewhat significant seems to have been forgotten. Remember that guy who was one vote away from being lynched (thanks to Carl, a "veteran") a couple days back? Where's he got to huh? His last post was the sorta flimsy wish-washy non-defense when that was all going on, and nothing since. I'm all for going after other people, but I would like to here from Sparks too. It seems like he's "given up", and that's a little concerning. 

-This post was updated as I read the posts, so the stuff at the top could be out of date by the time it reaches the bottom, it should just contain my opinions of various players and the things they have said this game-

Wonk and Spurge have said that I'm probably Mafia so many times already, now they're just confirming it amongst eachother- it's particularly concerning to me because I don't even think Spurge is Mafia; not so sure about Wonk, maybe I'll see something else during the 233 posts that I'm about to read.

Truck is being much more subtle about the whole thing; it's not the first time that he's suggested I could just be "bad town" this game - I would definitely use a similar argument if I was Mafia and I was trying to set up a situation in a couple of days time where I'm going to be suggesting that it's good if I [Radish] am lynched regardless of my alignment. Trucks could well be mafia.

Prof is probably town, but he's seemed less in-your-face about the whole thing this time. I don't think that changes in tone mean anything for a player as experienced as Prof, but it's worth considering that his changing feelings towards the game could have an impact on the decisions he makes. Anybody that he kind-of suspects right now (will probably discover those as I read on) would almost certainly have undergone some serious questioning under the "old" Prof.

Sparks claims Vanilla marine, which concerns me - I would never claim vanilla town if I was Mafia, so I'm willing to believe that he's telling the truth and is actually town. Not only this, but yet another vanilla marine suggests that there really aren't that many crazy power roles in this game. We've got to use what we've got to find and kill the mafia during the DAYTIME, rather than rely on our night-time abilities.

I've changed my mind on Impertinence for now, I think he could well be town. Asking the right questions, making good observations - and yet gives off a vibe of a player who genuinely is searching for the answers rather than somebody who knows them already and is just hiding it.

WhiteEagle is basically confirmed town in my opinion with that whole exchange about his role/name.

Haha! Wonk remembers my love for being the hammer vote :D I think he might be town after all.
Sparks and Trucks as Mafia, I could really see happening.

Still have no clue about ConeyG! I thought he was maybe Mafia based on the tones I was getting from some of his posts, but I'm not very familiar with his style so I can't rely on such things in this situation.
There is probably one Mafia hiding among the particularly afk players (even more so than me!) although I'm planning on posting more...missed half a day and so many posts ;-;

Welcome to the game, Khan!

Spurge is still placing his anti-Radish sentiments into the town this game, but I don't think he's actually doing it because he's mafia, which is unusual.

Yeah, I definitely think that Impertinence is town - he seemed genuinely concerned about my alignment when I failed to make a post at the end of day 1 (I would have been too!)

Aaaaaand now something potentially interesting is happening with Carl. However I am not one of the players who wants him to roleclaim, that seems way too dangerous to be doing this early. Put him on a watchlist and consider him in future days - people with the suitable power roles must check him out.

I think Spurge has already made his position on my participation pretty clear anyway

Some nice input there Radish, thanks for that. 

I have a question about these two paragraphs however. You're basically saying that you think Sparks is town, but then you change that opinion to Mafia without any reasoning. I understand you're not editing and just providing opinions, which is great and it shows with other users, but this bothers me a little. Why change your mind on Sparks?