and then silence....
first imps vote seems way out of place, since white talked of his role long before kahn was in the game. kahn mentions that he thinks he has the same role. Even confirmed the extra defense, before whites question.
So what was taken as role hunting, I saw as him trying to make sure that kahn isn't just saying the same role, but has something more to back it up.
so HOS on imp
Carl though is something else. He can make decent case with the words that white has used, but between how he did that yesterday with Nick, and his putting sparks at L1 so early, I don't see that my vote can be anywhere else.
Unvote
Vote Carl