By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Uncharted 4 vs Halo 5 vs Zelda U: Which will sell the most and be the highest rated?

DeduS on 20 July 2014

best seller: Halo 5
highest rated: Zelda U



 

Around the Network
Aura7541 on 20 July 2014
UpwardRapier said:
A lot of people don't realize, the halo 5 beta is coming out this year, that beta alone will make people get a xbox one, and when microsoft turns on the hype switch for guardians, sony's uncharted will not be able to stop it.

Think about it, Halo 5 guardians is going to be the destiny of 2015 next holiday season.

I don't think the beta alone will make people get an Xbox One just like that. Also, you have to consider Destiny which is being made by the original people that made Halo as great as it is today. What if people start jumping ship from Halo to Destiny, especially when the PS4 has significantly larger marketshare and about a third of the PS4 userbase is Wii/360-only users? All Bungie needs to do is put "From the makers of the Halo series" in ads and the front of the gamebox. People will instantly recognize it and will want to buy Destiny. The Halo series, quality-wise, has been in decline since Halo 3. A lot of people were disappointed with Halo 4, the first Halo not made by Bungie.

Add onto the fact that Halo 5 is facing even tougher competition such as COD, Battlefield, and Homefront, it will definitely not be a cakewalk for Halo 5. This isn't to say Halo 5 won't sell well and not move hardware. If MS goes about this smartly, then it'll definitely sell a lot.



mochachino on 20 July 2014

Rating:
Zelda
Uncharted
Halo

Sales:
Halo
Uncharted
Zelda



Kane1389 on 20 July 2014

Highest rated can either be UC4 or Zelda.

Best selling is definitely going to be Uncharted 4 tho. A successful 'core' IP that became popular in the previous gen always explodes with popularity in the next gen (the 1st installment does at least). Unacharted 4 is going to be PS4's Halo 3



Nirvana_Nut85 on 20 July 2014

Zelda U hands down should have the highest rating with sales going to Halo.



" Rebellion Against Tyrants Is Obedience To God"

Around the Network
Captain_Tom on 20 July 2014

Of course Uncharted 4 for both.



tak13 on 20 July 2014
fps_d0minat0r said:
tak13 said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
Sales:
Uncharted, Halo, Zelda
Simply because of consoles sold

Meta:
Uncharted, Zelda, Halo

Even if uncharted doesnt win meta it wont be by much and it will probably still win most the GOTY awards.


because of consoles sold ...you re wrong ...xb halo and zelda  n64 sold more than uncharted ps3!

 

Youre wrong because all those consoles were from a different generation and all those games are better/worse (compared to the competition) than they are today.

First lets get Zelda out of the way. That has no chance of winning sales even if half of all wii U owners buy it. Just for reference, MK8 has so far been bought by less than a third of wii U owners.      what just did you say,another person who is doubting mk8?...6.6  wii u 2million mk8  8.4ps4 2mill watchdogs...its a huge sucess ,selling 2mill in a base of 6.6,and you re presenting this to me ,as a failure...

As for Halo, its up against COD, BF, destiny (made by bungie), titanfall, homefront, next crysis

Compared to the original xbox, thats a lot more and much stronger compeitiion and they have also lost bungie who are now directly competing with it. Times are a lot harder for halo now than they were on the original xbox when basically anyone who played online was playing halo. Last gen that changed when COD and BF became big, and this gen its going to do destiny, titanfall and maybe others. The quality gap which Halo had over competitors simply does not exist anymore.

Then look at uncharted. Arguably the best development studio in the industry at the moment. Their last game got over 200 GOTY awards, the uncharted games have got hundreds.

And despite tps being a weaker genre than fps and halo being more established than uncharted, uncharted 3 sales were just ~2m behind halo 4. The difference in userbase between the X1 and PS4 will take care of that.

So yeah.... youre wrong.

 who cares about awards or the studio ... estimated after I looked previous gen sales...  uncharted is 3million behind halo 4!as for the difference in userbase i told you ,halo of xb 24mill  has sold more than uncharted 3 ps3 82mill, also nintendo gamecube inspite of 22mill sales managed to have big software  so  size of userbase sometimes is pointlessI!halo is the ms mascot...of course will win zelda and uncharted!i m not disproving,HALO -ZELDA-UNCHARTED..ooo i m  a nintendo fan and i m defending halo...wow!save this...lets see  who will be verified...



darkshadow23 on 20 July 2014

Ratings:
Uncharted
Zelda
Halo

Sales:
Uncharted
Halo
Zelda

People love Naughty Dog games so they will get good reviews and the PS4 is the console to have now... so sales to Uncharted too. Could be completely different though.



SecondWar on 20 July 2014

Normally would say Halo would sell the most but as the ps4 will more than likely have an even greater user base advantage over the x1, Uncharted could outsell it. It depends how many people get an x1 in the lead up to Halo's release just for Halo.

Zedla won't come close as it's not going to get any major sales with the low user base that the wii u has. Plus the x1 will likely have outsold it by then.



fps_d0minat0r on 21 July 2014
tak13 said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
tak13 said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
Sales:
Uncharted, Halo, Zelda
Simply because of consoles sold

Meta:
Uncharted, Zelda, Halo

Even if uncharted doesnt win meta it wont be by much and it will probably still win most the GOTY awards.


because of consoles sold ...you re wrong ...xb halo and zelda  n64 sold more than uncharted ps3!

 

Youre wrong because all those consoles were from a different generation and all those games are better/worse (compared to the competition) than they are today.

First lets get Zelda out of the way. That has no chance of winning sales even if half of all wii U owners buy it. Just for reference, MK8 has so far been bought by less than a third of wii U owners.      what just did you say,another person who is doubting mk8?...6.6  wii u 2million mk8  8.4ps4 2mill watchdogs...its a huge sucess ,selling 2mill in a base of 6.6,and you re presenting this to me ,as a failure...

As for Halo, its up against COD, BF, destiny (made by bungie), titanfall, homefront, next crysis

Compared to the original xbox, thats a lot more and much stronger compeitiion and they have also lost bungie who are now directly competing with it. Times are a lot harder for halo now than they were on the original xbox when basically anyone who played online was playing halo. Last gen that changed when COD and BF became big, and this gen its going to do destiny, titanfall and maybe others. The quality gap which Halo had over competitors simply does not exist anymore.

Then look at uncharted. Arguably the best development studio in the industry at the moment. Their last game got over 200 GOTY awards, the uncharted games have got hundreds.

And despite tps being a weaker genre than fps and halo being more established than uncharted, uncharted 3 sales were just ~2m behind halo 4. The difference in userbase between the X1 and PS4 will take care of that.

So yeah.... youre wrong.

 who cares about awards or the studio ... estimated after I looked previous gen sales...  uncharted is 3million behind halo 4!as for the difference in userbase i told you ,halo of xb 24mill  has sold more than uncharted 3 ps3 82mill, also nintendo gamecube inspite of 22mill sales managed to have big software  so  size of userbase sometimes is pointlessI!halo is the ms mascot...of course will win zelda and uncharted!i m not disproving,HALO -ZELDA-UNCHARTED..ooo i m  a nintendo fan and i m defending halo...wow!save this...lets see  who will be verified...


I didnt say MK8 was a failure, I actually said the opposite by using MK8 as a best case scenario for zelda, based on how successful it is.

I dont think Zelda can do better than MK8 because MK8 is appealing to more people.

So even assuming the best case for Zelda, its still not going to beat halo or uncharted.

And I already explained why I dont think halo 5 will sell as well on xb1 as first halo did on the original xbox. If you dont agree then fine.