The Halo value proposition is so much higher, and the games are older. TLOU was just out and there's not nearly as much reason to upgrade.

Halo Collection has shot to number 1 on Amazon best sellers, so that's something.

Don't really care about Halo either, but I'd still take Halo since The Last of Us has no replay value; Sorry - but no to higher resolution giraffes.

sony fanboys are getting ridiculous.
a whole franchise vs a game?
Cmon man, a game of a generation? I doubt it.
even it is a game of generation, there is still no chance to beat a whole franchise of master chief.

100+ MP maps, so obviously Halo.

Yah, it's ridiculous value.  At 10 minutes a match, it takes 1000 minutes or almost 17 hours to play each map once.  Not counting lobby time.  

I've bought every Halo game and every DLC pack and I'd pay way over $60 to buy it all agian playable on my new console for the next decade. 

Pre-ordered instantly.

Personally I loved TLOU, cant wait for part 2 not really intrested in replaying it already though, Halo all games on my xbox1 I'm geeked about.

Maybe when the TLOU 2 comes out I would buy 1 to rerun through it. But ya this gives me a reason to bury my 360 and move on for sure.

The Halo collection is easily the better value, 4 games for $60 is great!

But, the poll is which is more exciting...and TLOU was the best game I played last generation...so yeah, that one.

The only DLC pack I'm missing is the 3rd one for Halo 4 (I forget what it was called) and that's only because I stopped playing for awhile and now no one is ever on it so I've just kinda been hoping I'd catch it on sale. 

Hmcc just but i do dread the painful slow installation process that will come with it

The answer lies within the game that will be played more five years from now.