By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - E3 Scoring - Who will win?

 

Who will win?

Sony 134 33.58%
 
Nintendo 177 44.36%
 
Microsoft 32 8.02%
 
VGC Polls are useless 54 13.53%
 
Total:397
MDMAlliance on 08 June 2014

It will be interesting to see how the scores add up. Can't say I'm sure that Nintendo will do well on this scoring system, but we'll see.



Around the Network
Mike_L on 08 June 2014
vivster said:
Mike_L said:

x} You said that..

I'm gonna laugh a little if Sony loses this game after all the "this scoring system is shite".

Sony's penchant for 1 hour exclusive content and bad jokes could certainly mean just that.

The list is still heavily biased to his opinion though. Motion controls are not a bad thing, as are kids on stage.

The items and points seem overall very arbitrary. It sounds like a list of what would be fun for him and not what would have the broadest appeal to everyone watching.

I agree that we cannot criticize Microsoft for the lack of must have Kinect games and at the same time criticize them for showing Kinect games..

Still motion controls and kids on stage do seem to receive a lot of negativity from the common vg user whether it's Move, Kinect or Wii Play and since this is a thread on vg I think it's fair to perceive it from our point of view.

 

Maybe we should have 5 completely unbiased users in a jury that can decide whether the specific motion control game is good or bad.. or just delete the part with motion controls from the rules :P



animegaming on 08 June 2014

whoever says "Will be Released in 2014" the most wins E3



vivster on 08 June 2014
Mike_L said:
vivster said:
Mike_L said:

x} You said that..

I'm gonna laugh a little if Sony loses this game after all the "this scoring system is shite".

Sony's penchant for 1 hour exclusive content and bad jokes could certainly mean just that.

The list is still heavily biased to his opinion though. Motion controls are not a bad thing, as are kids on stage.

The items and points seem overall very arbitrary. It sounds like a list of what would be fun for him and not what would have the broadest appeal to everyone watching.

I agree that we cannot criticize Microsoft for the lack of must have Kinect games and at the same time criticize them for showing Kinect games..

Still motion controls and kids on stage do seem to receive a lot of negativity from the common vg user whether it's Move, Kinect or Wii Play and since this is a thread on vg I think it's fair to perceive it from our point of view.

 

Maybe we should have 5 completely unbiased users in a jury that can decide whether the specific motion control game is good or bad.. or just delete the part with motion controls from the rules :P

Lol. Unbiased users on VGC^^

That's a good one.



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

Mike_L on 08 June 2014
vivster said:

Lol. Unbiased users on VGC^^

That's a good one.

C'mon! We do have some of those.. Don't we?



Around the Network
vivster on 08 June 2014
Mike_L said:
vivster said:

Lol. Unbiased users on VGC^^

That's a good one.

C'mon! We do have some of those.. Don't we?

I guess we will never know.

I could pretend to be unbiased and only write generic "yay for gaming" or "EA sucks" posts but that wouldn't be fun. Even the most unbiased people here will have their biases.

I mean look at me. Even though I'm a Nintendo fan I'm a total Nintendo hater. I'm biased in BOTH ways.



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

JWeinCom on 08 June 2014

Not sure if serious. If so, then I'd say that you can't really judge it that way because it doesn't incorporate the quality of the games which is in and of itself subjective. If Nintendo announced Wonderful 102 for instance, I'd be stoked, and if Sony announced Uncharted 4, I'd yawn. Different people like different things so any attempt at an objective measure would be difficult.



Frogger on 08 June 2014
KylieDog said:
spemanig said:


It benefits the consumer who gets to play the title.


They would get it if it was not exclusive.  So where is the benefit?

Don't bring first parties into this, expecting them to be multiplat is silly, the rule is for third parties.


An exclusive is an exclusive. You don't get to single one out one just because of who made it. Wither way, someone gets to play it, and someone doesn't.



NintendoCM on 08 June 2014

losing points for no conference, that's completely idiotic...
I think the winner will be close between Nintendo and Sony



Mike_L on 08 June 2014
KylieDog said:

Name one good motion controls demo in the last 6 years. They've all been awful or gone horribly wrong somehow. Or just faked.

I agree. I still hated everything PS Move and most casual Wii games even though I tend to like the offerings from Sony and Nintendo more than Microsoft's (it's just a stupid opinion, I don't have stocks in any of the companies and I don't have a personal hate towards Microsoft, Dead Rising 3 and Sunset Overdrive seem great).

But what if the motion controls are combined with a strong showing of Project Morpheus that you like personally? Maybe we should just keep our minds open and perceive every individual game whether it's motion controlled or not. If it's really bad we can just score it as a bad joke..

I know you're just trying to structure some undebatable rules so that everything doesn't drown in personal opinions and arguments post E3.