E3 Scoring - Who will win?

[Mike_L]

vivster said:

Mike_L said:

x} You said that..

I'm gonna laugh a little if Sony loses this game after all the "this scoring system is shite".

Sony's penchant for 1 hour exclusive content and bad jokes could certainly mean just that.

The list is still heavily biased to his opinion though. Motion controls are not a bad thing, as are kids on stage.

The items and points seem overall very arbitrary. It sounds like a list of what would be fun for him and not what would have the broadest appeal to everyone watching.

I agree that we cannot criticize Microsoft for the lack of must have Kinect games and at the same time criticize them for showing Kinect games..

Still motion controls and kids on stage do seem to receive a lot of negativity from the common vg user whether it's Move, Kinect or Wii Play and since this is a thread on vg I think it's fair to perceive it from our point of view.

 

Maybe we should have 5 completely unbiased users in a jury that can decide whether the specific motion control game is good or bad.. or just delete the part with motion controls from the rules :P