+Far Cry 4
- The Witness

+ The Evil Within
- Dragon Age

107 votes in 12 hours, are you kidding me!

+ Evolve
- Mario Kart

Updating now

Indeed, if History has something to prove, that's The Witcher.

Whereas the first game in each installment, Dragon Age was vastly superior, The Witcher was still a solid title (and much, much older than DA:O. In fact, it used a modified Neverwinter Nights 2 engine to make it run).

Then you have the sequels, where Dragon Age 2 succeeded in some areas, it also failed horribly in some other. On the other hand, you have The Witcher 2, which completely improved over its predecessors in every single area (minus longevity; the first game was longer).

And now we have DA:Inquisition and The Witcher 3. The first one has a lot to prove; the second one comes with positive buzz. It's up to Bioware to prove they still have it; CD Projeckt Red doesn't need to prove anything, as they have shown they're talented devs.

1. The Division - 31
2. Mario Kart 8 - 7
3. Evolve - 15
4. Super Smash Bros - 30
5. Yoshi's Yarn - 19
6. Below - 29
7. The Evil Within - 13
8. Dragon Age: Inquisition - 29
9 Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor - 30
10. Dying Light - 4
11. Mirrors Edge 2 - 30
12. No Man's Sky - 32
13. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - 36
14. The Witness - 6
15. Legend of Zelda: U - 17
16. Far Cry 4 - 34
17. Earthlock - 24
18. Mass Effect 4 - 14

Graveyard:

Fantasia Music Evolved
Watchdogs
Driveclub
Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare
Sunset Overdrive
The Order 1886
Destiny
Fable Legends
Quantum Break
Final Fantasy XV
Assassins Creed Unity
Alien: Isolation
X
Project Spark
Sonic Boom
Halo 5
Batman: Arkham Knight
Uncharted 4
The Crew
Deep Down
Bayonetta 2
Metro 2033: Redux
Kingdom Hearts 3
D4

Updated as of 11:50am GMT - Seece

-Dying Light
+Zelda (Mario Kart looks too late to save, and it's out now anyway, so it's not really "upcoming")

+ No Man's Sky
- MK8

+ the witness
fuck slade
- dying light. (dead now)

+ Mass Effect 4
- Zelda

+ dragon age
-yoshi