I love Nintendo games but they just don't come in enough volume for me to survive only on them. I have Smash, SMG1&2, Zelda SS, and some classics on Wii but I have kept (and I only keep my very favorite games that I go back to replay at LEAST once a year so these are pretty much my classics and that includes those Wii games) GoW3 and Ascension, Uncharted 1-3, Infamous 1-2, Ratchet FToD, Q4B, Nexus, and ACiT, Resistance 3, LBP2, Journey, Flower, Infamous FoB, Puppeteer, Sly 4, LoU, Twisted Metal, and I'm sure I'm forgetting a few but you probably see that there's just more to keep me entertained on PS3. Not to mention I prefer HD remakes over getting games on VC so past first party stuff is also going to be preferable on Sony platforms.
I reiterate that I would HATE to choose because I LOVE Nintendo games, but in the end Sony just gives me more which is why I buy their consoles earlier in the lifecycle and end up getting more software. Hell over half my PS3 library (PS+ games not included) is 1st party. Nintendo is all first party but it's only about 10 games this gen.