MS might win in terms of exclusives right now, but do your dormmates care which console has the superior versions of multiplat games?

Actually the first titan fall is coming to xbox 360 , xbox one and pc. Ps4 is not getting teh game. Plus drive club already got delayed wwith no new date as to when its coming out. Who knows it may not come out this year. I to can mention upcoming xbox one games such as quantum break, titan fall, halo 5 or teh rumored halo 2 anniversary, project spark , kinect sports rivals, loco cycle, sunset overdrive to name a few. Apart from titan fall teh rest are all exclusives to xbox one which is more then what you listed as upcoming ps4 games :)

but we cant include those titles because one, we arent sure if its true yet. and two, why should sony be docked because they didnt have a leak? Obviously MS wasnt ready to reveal yet and we shouldnt include it till they are (and by that time im sure sony will be ready to reveal their hand)

@max not really helpful since i am askling about the game titles not teh average metacritic scores plus metacritic scores are biased as i could easily log in and give multiple 0s for killzone which tehn causes the average to drop lol.

Seen the list and your comparison is not really fair as at least 7 of teh games that are above 75% also exist on xbox one . However they are not entered for xbox one. The funniest things is that teh ones above 75% for ps4 are all indie games. The two AAA exclusives are below teh mark. AT least some xbox one AAA exclusives are above 75% ;)

the 18 titles arent based on user reviews. 

@Max i know that but looks like you didn't understand teh question. I wanted you to list out the names of those 18titles which you claim to have gotten and average reviewer score of 75% and above. Plus reviewer website scores are always bias as its tailored to the reviewer personal taste. For example if me and you were reviewers for KZ and War frame i would give it a lower score then you would . Most of the time there are games that get bad marks from reviwers but turns out to be a really good game. Nice try though :)

@ethomaz well it has to be fair to begin with as on the metacritic website,, their multiplats game scores that haven't been added to xbox one list but has been added to the ps4 list. Till then the comparsison is mute :)

He did say they all had PS3's.

So, no.