Almost said FFXIII, but 83 on meta seems fair enough to me. Nevertheless, i still dont understand the massive hate around the game.

Back on topic, Dust an elysian tail its a wonderful game yet, nobody seems to care about it U_U

I guess I prefer "games might have over looked" as not sure about ratings.

1. Puppeteer - This could have been another Little Big Planet, but for some reason it did not click with just about anyone it appears.

2. Rayman Legends - I know the whole Wii U delay caused issues, still an amazing game that followed up Origins in great fashion.

3. Sly Cooper 4 - Far superior to 2 and 3 for me, yet so many people acted like it was archaic when I saw a classic 3D plat former.

4. Catherine - One of the most unique and fascinating games I played this generation in terms of story and gameplay. It did about as well as expected, but hoped it would reach more.

5. Lollipop Chainsaw - Ignoring the baseball segment this game was a blast to play and yet seemed to garner a tepid response. Hopefully get to revisit it next gen.

1.NieR
2.NieR
3.NieR
4.NieR
5.NieR

El Shaddai
Spec Ops the line
Nier
Lost Odyssey
Majin and the forsaken kingdom

Won't rank them as would take too long too decide haha:

Nier- the obvious one if you ask me. Great characters, story, and overall atmosphere. Truly a gem of the generation which unfortunately no one played and critics panned for reasons I have still yet to understand. Don't worry Kaine I know your story.

Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World- yes I know it isn't as good as the first but I still enjoyed this game a lot despite the harsh reviews it got from critics and fans alike. Can't wait for the HD version in the coming months. Will gladly put another 100 hours into it.

Record of Agarest War: really any of the Agarest war games. I have beat the first one and Zero and almost done with number 2. I think the serious is fantastic. However, out of all of my choices, I can see why this one isn't very popular.

Magna Carta 2- I love this game haha. Really enjoyed the battle system and story. Maybe not the best RPG but I think people would enjoy it if they gave it a chance.

Halo 3: ODST- I still think this is the best single-player Halo game made (although Halo 4 came close). The story was well written and the characters were some of the best in the series. It was a complete and concise story which bar the first Halo game, has been missing in the series. Before Halo fans jump on me, I have played every Halo game in the series and a huge Halo fan (ask Outlawauron) so don't see this as trolling Halo. I think the way this game has been panned by fans has been unfortunate considering how good Bungie did on it.

Other mentions would be Infinite Undiscovery, LotR: War in the North, every Suda game haha, Enslaved, and Zack & Wiki.

Personally I enjoyed ODST far more than Halo Reach..Halo 4 got the series back on track for me (though not to the same classic status Halo 1 and Halo 2 share.

Well glad someone else liked it as much as I did.  I wasn't a personal fan of Halo Reach though both single player and multiplayer.  Felt like it took the series back a step.

I liked the game for sure and it was a really good way to renew the aging Halo 3 and anytime I want a classic Xbox live experience I always go back and play Halo 3 ODST or the original Halo on PC.

Rayman legends is one of the highest rated games of the year?? 

All I can say is:

Remember Me and Xenoblade