By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - Will Pokemon XY Become The Top Selling 3DS Game? *I Was Right*

Slade6alpha said:
Yes, I firmly believe Pokemon XY will be the top selling 3DS game, ever; nothing will surpass it. I'm willing to bet on that too :)

I'm willing to bet on it too. :)



Around the Network
Aielyn said:
007BondAgent said:
Pokemon XY is being bundled with 2DS's in north america and europe

So what? It'll have the same effect on Pokemon XY sales as the Mario 3D Land bundle had on Mario 3D Land sales. What is different about the deal going on in Europe/Australia now is that Mario 3D Land is a freebie that comes when you buy a 3DS XL with one of a set of games. It's not bundled, it's a deal. So people will be getting Mario 3D Land as a result of buying another game, rather than getting it with their system.


I'm not saying the Pokemon bundle will have the same effect, as the give away, i just think it will be enough to stop mario's legs.



007BondAgent said:
I'm not saying the Pokemon bundle will have the same effect, as the give away, i just think it will be enough to stop mario's legs.

Why would it stop Mario's legs? It might help Pokemon's legs a little, maybe. But the point I'm actually making is that 3D Land will have a lot more digital sales than it's given credit for, because there's no way to track claims of the 3D Land deal (other than internally by Nintendo). The Pokemon bundle, on the other hand, will be tracked because it comes pre-installed, and thus it can be easily tracked. Pre-installed numbers will presumably be tracked by VGChartz, whereas digital download deals can't be tracked.



007BondAgent said:
Jizz_Beard_thePirate said:
007BondAgent said:
Jizz_Beard_thePirate said:
Smash Bros on the 3ds will probably sell more

No it won't, not even close

Smash bros 3DS Plus Wii U, won't even outsell Pokemon XY

Well... This is the first Smash Bros on handheld plus the Smash Bros on wiiU and 3ds have different stages that are unique to each other which gives more incentive to buy both copies... Also the wiiU's install base isn't nearly as high so I think it will outsell Pokemon XY

1. There has never been a smash bros game on a handheld, so it has no audience

2. No smash bros game has outsold a pokemon game, so i don't know how you get this idea, that this will change that.

Well... Technically, according to vgchartz (unless I am reading it wrong, still a noob here), Brawl has out sold: Pokémon Platinum, Pokemon Black / White 2, and Pokémon Heart Gold / Soul Silver on the DS... But I suppose you do have a point with the audience thing.

http://www.vgchartz.com/game/6962/super-smash-bros-brawl/

http://www.vgchartz.com/gamedb/?name=pokemon



                  

PC Specs: CPU: 7800X3D || GPU: Strix 4090 || RAM: 32GB DDR5 6000 || Main SSD: WD 2TB SN850

wow look at those Mario 3D land sales and these don't even include digital ones. I'm sure it's licking the 10m by now and will be the best selling 3D Mario yet

not sure about it but it looks possible unless MK sells over 17-18m as I'm sure Pokemon will reach that once Z comes out



    R.I.P Mr Iwata :'(

Around the Network

No way XY will sell 8 mil by the end of this year. Impossible, the series is in decline.



the_dengle said:

No way XY will sell 8 mil by the end of this year. Impossible, the series is in decline.


Lawlight is that you :P



I look for mario kart 7 to have a big 1st quater of 2014, pokemon x and y as well but, mario kart is a game that has a huge broad audience anyone can play it and have fun, whereas pokemon is a rpg with a more limited fanbase. With that said i think both games will top 13 million in their lifetime but mario kart 7 will prolly get the edge by a million or so.



007BondAgent said:
Jizz_Beard_thePirate said:
007BondAgent said:
Jizz_Beard_thePirate said:
Smash Bros on the 3ds will probably sell more

No it won't, not even close

Smash bros 3DS Plus Wii U, won't even outsell Pokemon XY

Well... This is the first Smash Bros on handheld plus the Smash Bros on wiiU and 3ds have different stages that are unique to each other which gives more incentive to buy both copies... Also the wiiU's install base isn't nearly as high so I think it will outsell Pokemon XY

1. There has never been a smash bros game on a handheld, so it has no audience

2. No smash bros game has outsold a pokemon game, so i don't know how you get this idea, that this will change that.


#2 is correct.

#1 You cant say that, your going to eat your own words, im not saying it'll sell 10mil+ on 3DS but their are plenty of games that swtched (handheld~console) and got plenty of sales if not more than where it originally came from!

Most of the time it never does (go up) as show in lots of games but lets not forget LM2 that sold over 3mil in its first year (its currently alot higher) and will outsell its homeconsole counterpart with its 3.6mil sales.

But there are some games that people are in denial that think it'll sell great (as good or better) by switching from HH to consoles or vise versa (pokemon for an example will never sell even half of wat it would do on home console vs its HH counterpart)

That said SSB can surprise us as it is a WildCard! Im getting 3 copies of SSB for 3DS (2 at launch) with 1 copy of SSB for WiiU! Why? Cuz its a game thats worth it playing with your friends (in my case my bro+sis) and that right there will happen alot do it being on HH. It can go anywhere from as low as 2mil or as high as 8mil! we dont kno cuz its never happened before!!!



Jizz_Beard_thePirate said:
007BondAgent said:
Jizz_Beard_thePirate said:
007BondAgent said:
Jizz_Beard_thePirate said:
Smash Bros on the 3ds will probably sell more

No it won't, not even close

Smash bros 3DS Plus Wii U, won't even outsell Pokemon XY

Well... This is the first Smash Bros on handheld plus the Smash Bros on wiiU and 3ds have different stages that are unique to each other which gives more incentive to buy both copies... Also the wiiU's install base isn't nearly as high so I think it will outsell Pokemon XY

1. There has never been a smash bros game on a handheld, so it has no audience

2. No smash bros game has outsold a pokemon game, so i don't know how you get this idea, that this will change that.

Well... Technically, according to vgchartz (unless I am reading it wrong, still a noob here), Brawl has out sold: Pokémon Platinum, Pokemon Black / White 2, and Pokémon Heart Gold / Soul Silver on the DS... But I suppose you do have a point with the audience thing.

http://www.vgchartz.com/game/6962/super-smash-bros-brawl/

http://www.vgchartz.com/gamedb/?name=pokemon


Even though thats true those arent a new gen pair games!

In pokemon there are 3 types of games (mainline)

New Gen Pair= Biggest in sales and are the games introducing the new generation with many changes+Additional Pokemon+New Region+Etc

Director's Cut= The third version of a game from the spinoffs. Introduces New Tutor Moves+Adds lots of extra Content+New Formes of Pokemon+The better version of the original pair(BW2 was different as it had a new story+extra feats in it)

Remakes= Even if they are remakes they are far surperior than their original counterparts due to what system it was originally on. These arent just your typical remakes, they beef up everything in it, making them feel like new games as well as a remake!

New Gen Pair= (15mil+ Sales) R/G/B+G/S+R/S+D/P+B/W+X/Y (6 games)

Directors Cut= (6.5mil-9mil) Yellow+Crstal+Emerald+Platinum+BW2 (5 games) [Yellow sold 14mil but it was a one time thing]

Remakes= (10.5mil-12mil) FireRed/LeafGreen+HeartGold/SoulSilver (2 games)

3DS will have a Ruby/Sapphire Remake and it'll sell less than the others but still do really well. Pokemon XY will sell over at least 14mil