So if XB1 had 5 90+ games and 10 5 rated games, and the PS4 had 3 80 rated games, the PS4 line up is better because its average is higher?

Averaging out the scores is stupid unless there is an even amount of games. Fact is XB1 has an exclusive rated on par with Killzone (KI) and one that'll be above Reso (Forza) and then Zoo Tycoon, Ryse, Power Star and Dead Rising to boot which PS4 has nothing to counter with.

I've done better than that, I've watched people play it myself. I've read comments by people that have played it, "half way in in 30 minutes" or whatever that thread was, in reality it's around 7 hours long.

Looking through this thread... that Knack score is downright criminal.

Compiled from current metacritic figures that have more than a single review:

Battlefield 4 87
NBA 2K14 85
Need for Speed: Rivals 84
Resogun 82
Assassin's Creed IV 82
Call of Duty: Ghosts 78
Killzone: Shadow Fall 74
Contrast 67
Knack 58

PS4 average: 77.4

Call of Duty: Ghosts 78
Dead Rising 3 78
Killer Instinct 74
Zoo Tycoon 72
Powerstar Golf 68
Crimson Dragon 56
Lococycle 53

Xbox One average: 68.4

Assuming BF4, NBA and NFS:Rivals score roughly the same (currently no scores given):

Battlefield 4 87
NBA 2K14 85
Need for Speed: Rivals 84
Resogun 82
Assassin's Creed IV 82
Call of Duty: Ghosts 78
Killzone: Shadow Fall 74
Contrast 67
Knack 58

PS4 average: 77.4

Battlefield 4 87
NBA 2K14 85
Need for Speed: Rivals 84
Call of Duty: Ghosts 78
Dead Rising 3 78
Killer Instinct 74
Zoo Tycoon 72
Powerstar Golf 68
Crimson Dragon 56
Lococycle 53

Xbox One average: 73.5


Aaaaand WiiU as requested..

Mass Effect 3: Special Edition 87
Assassin's Creed III 85
NBA 2K13 85
Batman: Arkham City – Armored Edition 85
Darksiders II 85
New Super Mario Bros. U 84
Tekken Tag Tournament 2: Wii U Edition 83
Call of Duty: Black Ops II 81
Skylanders: Giants 80
Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed 78
ZombiU 77
Nintendo Land 77
Your Shape: Fitness Evolved 2013 76
Madden NFL 13 75
Scribblenauts Unlimited 74
Fifa 13 69
Ninja Gaiden 3: Razor's Edge 69
Just Dance 4 66
Warriors Orochi 3 Hyper 64
SiNG PARTY 60
Epic Mickey 2: The Power of Two 57
Transformers: Prime – The Game 56
Rabbids Land 52
Funky Barn 50
Tank! Tank! Tank! 45
Ben 10: Omniverse 43
ESPN Sports Connection 31
Game Party Champions 24

Average for WiiU: 67.7

Despite having way more launch titles, it had way more bombas too, draging the average down to 67.7

That's horrible logic. It just shows that PS4 has less to choose from. Besides, Lococycle and Crimson Dragon shouldn't be in that considering they're going to 360 too. So how about you make that even.

For somone who doesn't care about reivews you sure take them to heart when they suit you.

I have to say some fans are looking pretty desperate in here. Trying to compare 3 exclusives against 8. Taking an average of 3 scores versus 8 scores is pretty funny. I guess VGC never changes. Completely negating the Killer Instinct talk of being one of the best fighters ever made next year.

Its like Killer Instinct is KI Prologue. Gameplay fighting perfection.

It is always best to go by what is written in the review itself and not the overall score.

Take Killzone for example. Majority say it is the best in the series, yet it is scored 10 points lower than the KZ3, which is considered worse than KZ2.

Between everything we have seen so far, I would wager than Forza does not score 90+. Going by the logic used by reviewers throughout the last couple of weeks it should be an absolute impossibility.

If it does 90+ with half the content of the last game ill eat my hat. 

Okay so, selnor1983, if review scores dont matter to you, stop talking about them, and seece, we get it, you reeealy like xbox, but kindly stop twisting the rules to favor your chosen platform, when you compare launch offerings all of the games matter, regardless of multiplatform or exclusivity.