I'll give this more of a think in the morning

My reason for suspecting you is your vote at the same time as moreno's, so that's why I only pair you with him.  As for moreno/stefl, why would I suspect that?  I guess I can't think of a reason it should be impossible. 

I get that you think solo scum is more likely, but why don't you think that my reasoning for operating under the two scum hypothesis trumps it? 

I'd like to hear moreno's response to you, and then I'll explain.

Response 1:

Yeah. I admit I just voted because there was nothing else to do at that point.

Response 2:

At that point, 1 confirmed townie (Linkz) was as good as nothing and I did not want to reveal my role.

I didn't think the first point really deserved a response given nobody else gave any reasons, and I'm okay with the second answer.

So why a two-man team is quite unlikely:
FF+anyone makes no sense, if there's no doctor than why no kill?
moreno wouldn't make sense as scum, unless radish the miller is also scum. I still believe radish is town, and his miller claim fits with his opinion on everything he's said prior too.
From my perspective that leaves Stefl&radish, but even beyond my belief that radish is town I wouldn't expect them to hold back a kill.
Lastly, I find a two-man team that doesn't include Stefl to be extremely unlikely because it could basically allow scum to win without any lynches.

I'm leaning Stefl as our Mafia at the moment, but the claimed role makes sure that it's not an easy decision.

Yeah, Princess in a 6 player game is pretty broken.

I feel torn.

Lynching moreno would give us a LOT of information if we were wrong.

Linkz's vanilla claim sticks out pretty sorely what with all these powers.

Stefl's claimed power would be so devastating to town it's ridiculous, but I can imagine a mod thinking that the town powers would balance it ... what do you all think? Is our mod someone who would do that?

It could also be a fake claim to not only scare off a lynch, but also get me to protect him so he can finally kill someone

Honestly, Beloved Princess in a game that only has 6 players is a thing that should not happen when there is only one protection role and no blocks etc. Sure we had 2 investigators but what good does it do to know who the mafia are if they already used the extra night to win? Would AstroGamer really do this?

If Stefl is the last mafia then the town would look like this: Doc, Cop, Watcher, Miller, Townie, Mafia. That seems like a pretty swingy game but not incredibly unbalanced. Kinda stacked against the mafia IMO but I can see someone thinking that the cop isn't so bad because it would be just as likely to get the miller as the real mafia.

If it were moreno and linkz, it would be Doc, Watcher, Mafia, Mafia, Miller, Princess. That's way too stacked against town. Two mafia and the princess and the red-herring miller? Too much for just the doc and watcher to balance when a single mislynch and kill would end the game. (Or even no lynch and princess/extra death.)

If it were moreno and radish, it would be Doc, Watcher, Mafia, Mafia, Townie, Princess. Not quite as bad as with a miller but still pretty stacked against the town IMO.

I guess what I'm boiling this down to is that if there are two mafia, Stefl is probably one of them anyway. Otherwise this game is simply too stacked against town IMO.

Do any of you guys think Astro would put B.P. in a 6 player game?

I think going through the various combinations like that is the best way to go about this. And honestly, I think the following would be the most balanced combination:

Cop, Doc, Watcher, Princess, Miller, Mafia

Which would make Linkz the Mafia (I know this is assuming that there is just one mafia)

If we lynch Stefl and he's mafia and the game doesn't end:
me(doc), moreno(cop), Linkz(town), radish(miller)

radish: Cop, doc, watcher, town, scum, scum. Very powerful town, seems unfriendly to mafia but not insanely so.

Linkz: Cop, doc, watcher, GFscum, miller, scum. Cop is worse than useless, but town still gets 2 powers. It's swingy based on who cop investigates but not too bad.

moreno: Doc, watcher, scum, scum, miller, town. The red-herring miller is back, otherwise not too bad.

Final-Fan: If I was scum we'd be the most insane mafia ever. "Let's give up 2 nightkills and lynch one of us to fake out the town!"

Remember that the cop cleared Linkz.  So he'd be a Godfather and you'd be Miller, which would mean the Cop would be literally unable to find any mafia while also getting a false positive, on top of there being a princess.  Still you're right in that it's not a completely unbalanced game; the doc could still protect and the watcher could help make sense of things.  

The problem is that this is an actual reasonable possibility that means we could be killing ourselves by lynching the Princess.  Unless I continue my hot streak of course, but that would be asking too much lol.