Wow, that is very undertracked since VGchartz says its only sold 1.22 million. 

Shadows of the Damned is IMO a very fun game and very underrated too. Check it out too.

By the way, I still have one achievement to do: Finding all the damned coffee thermoses. I'm missing one, but since the game doesn't label them, I have to track them all one by one. A pain in the ass.

Use it if you want...

http://www.videogamesblogger.com/2010/05/17/alan-wake-coffee-thermoses-locations-guide-xbox-360.htm

I was using this, but I still have to go one-by-one T_T

I have seen Catherine, my buddy has it.  Kind of reminded me of a cross between Braid, Wake with a dash of henti thrown in for good measure.

I don't know about Catherine, but Alan Wake is one of the most pirated games - more people pirate it than purchased it according to VGC numbers.  Reports that over two million people have pirated it. :)  Not sure how that happened, but they even made a thing where Wake wears a pirate eye patch if it's bootlegged.  It is a shame too, because if that many people purchased the game, there would surly be more games like it.

Yes, I had to do that too.  I had only two left.  Two freaking thermoses in the entire game.  I'm writing down notes: the games should let you know where they are missing when their are just 10 or 5 left. 

There were ways in Red Dead to find when you were missing something like that.  (Oh, I just need two owl feathers? Ok.)

I was actually missing two near the very beginning.  A couple of those I think you would never find, unless someone told you to look. 

A few of the Nightmare Pages were a bit tricky as well.

But there's a big difference: you actually know which pages you are missing!

No way, it was at like 1m a year after launch. Do you have proof?

I have had all the achievements for this game plus the DLC for a while. I love the game.