By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 58: Avatar The Last Airbender

Yoshiya on 15 August 2013
benao87 said:
Nachomamma8 said:

STEFL confirmed scum. Cop linkz, don't protect him because he's probably scum. Don't have a handle on the third scum, but STRONG town are vetterman, yoshiya, spurge, final-fan.

I wish spurge hand't gone berserk, much more could've been achieved day 1.

What do you reckon now?

I think it's safe to lean on Stefl having been town rather than mafia. Poisoner is normally 3rd party (meaning that if he was 3rd party he wouldn't have been targeted by what we assume to be the poisoner) and if he was mafia it would have been unfair not to tell town (what if we lynched him and had no idea we'd actually achieved what we are supposed to do?). That and the way that Mario talks about it being sad in the flavour makes me think that's his way of saying that he's good. On the flip side, you are right to say that we can't confirm him, I just think it's safe to say he probably is.



Around the Network
benao87 on 15 August 2013
Yoshiya said:
benao87 said:
Nachomamma8 said:

STEFL confirmed scum. Cop linkz, don't protect him because he's probably scum. Don't have a handle on the third scum, but STRONG town are vetterman, yoshiya, spurge, final-fan.

I wish spurge hand't gone berserk, much more could've been achieved day 1.

What do you reckon now?

I think it's safe to lean on Stefl having been town rather than mafia. Poisoner is normally 3rd party (meaning that if he was 3rd party he wouldn't have been targeted by what we assume to be the poisoner) and if he was mafia it would have been unfair not to tell town (what if we lynched him and had no idea we'd actually achieved what we are supposed to do?). That and the way that Mario talks about it being sad in the flavour makes me think that's his way of saying that he's good. On the flip side, you are right to say that we can't confirm him, I just think it's safe to say he probably is.

Yeah, I also though that he might be a 3rd party, but the way FF died is more mafia-like, due to flavour, then his death had to came from a 3rd party.

Maybe it's prudent to think he is town, and assume that all the threats to town are still intact, and we do take extra care.



Complete comic

Linkzmax on 15 August 2013
supermario128 said:

As everyone was stumbling around Sokka tripped over something. To which Toph exclaimed, "You would never cut it as a blind person." The thing he tripped over was yet another lifeless body. This one was different though. They were not killed by fire or even lightning. This one appeared to have been poisoned as the half eaten cabbage lay beside the person. Upon further examination they could tell it was none other than King Bumi (Stefl). The villagers knew the intentions of this killer were good, but it was still sad to see the old king lying there dead. No one knew what sort of role the crazy, old King had.

You guys are picking apart flavor to analyze the kills, but nobody has mentioned this. If Stefl is being referred to as the killer,(mafia or 3rd party) then the rest of the sentence makes no sense. So Stefl was almost undoubtedly town, and as benao says it's best to assume that anyway.

And as for the intentions of the killer being good, that means Stefl's killer was either 3rd party gunning for mafia or a town "vig". I'd have to lean the latter as even 3rd party trying to hit mafia is still a threat to town.

So Nacho, did you kill Stefl?



VGC Mafia Archives

NoCtiS_NoX on 16 August 2013

Yoshiya is my number 1 suspect right now.

HoN: Yoshi

followed by astro



Yoshiya on 16 August 2013
Linkzmax said:
supermario128 said:

As everyone was stumbling around Sokka tripped over something. To which Toph exclaimed, "You would never cut it as a blind person." The thing he tripped over was yet another lifeless body. This one was different though. They were not killed by fire or even lightning. This one appeared to have been poisoned as the half eaten cabbage lay beside the person. Upon further examination they could tell it was none other than King Bumi (Stefl). The villagers knew the intentions of this killer were good, but it was still sad to see the old king lying there dead. No one knew what sort of role the crazy, old King had.

You guys are picking apart flavor to analyze the kills, but nobody has mentioned this. If Stefl is being referred to as the killer,(mafia or 3rd party) then the rest of the sentence makes no sense. So Stefl was almost undoubtedly town, and as benao says it's best to assume that anyway.

And as for the intentions of the killer being good, that means Stefl's killer was either 3rd party gunning for mafia or a town "vig". I'd have to lean the latter as even 3rd party trying to hit mafia is still a threat to town.

So Nacho, did you kill Stefl?

I took that to mean the intentions of the person that killed him.

NoCtiS_NoX said:
Yoshiya is my number 1 suspect right now. 

HoN: Yoshi

followed by astro

Care to elaborate?



Around the Network
Yoshiya on 16 August 2013

Oh, actually, I think I know why you think I'm suspicious. You saw me at Stefl didn't you?



AstroGamer on 16 August 2013
NoCtiS_NoX said:
Yoshiya is my number 1 suspect right now.

HoN: Yoshi

followed by astro


Could you elaborate on your suspicions. I have some suspicions on Yoshi too but I'm waiting on night to finish to confirm them. Also, trashleg and Baalz are a tad worrying since they haven't posted yet



My Hummingbird

3DS Friend Code: 047387541842

Nachomamma8 on 16 August 2013
Linkzmax said:
supermario128 said:

As everyone was stumbling around Sokka tripped over something. To which Toph exclaimed, "You would never cut it as a blind person." The thing he tripped over was yet another lifeless body. This one was different though. They were not killed by fire or even lightning. This one appeared to have been poisoned as the half eaten cabbage lay beside the person. Upon further examination they could tell it was none other than King Bumi (Stefl). The villagers knew the intentions of this killer were good, but it was still sad to see the old king lying there dead. No one knew what sort of role the crazy, old King had.

You guys are picking apart flavor to analyze the kills, but nobody has mentioned this. If Stefl is being referred to as the killer,(mafia or 3rd party) then the rest of the sentence makes no sense. So Stefl was almost undoubtedly town, and as benao says it's best to assume that anyway.

And as for the intentions of the killer being good, that means Stefl's killer was either 3rd party gunning for mafia or a town "vig". I'd have to lean the latter as even 3rd party trying to hit mafia is still a threat to town.

So Nacho, did you kill Stefl?

Why would I answer this with another night imminent? 



Nachomamma8 on 16 August 2013
AstroGamer said:
NoCtiS_NoX said:
Yoshiya is my number 1 suspect right now.

HoN: Yoshi

followed by astro


Could you elaborate on your suspicions. I have some suspicions on Yoshi too but I'm waiting on night to finish to confirm them. Also, trashleg and Baalz are a tad worrying since they haven't posted yet

Yoshiya is pretty much confirmed town with his last post; you should put those suspicions to bed.



supermario128 on 16 August 2013

Everyone was expecting the worst when they awoke from a quick nap that they had taken. Who else was going to be burnt, electrocuted, or poisoned; they all wondered... Little did they know Katara stayed up all night to keep a watch over everybody. Finally, someone was using their brains instead of senselessly killing random people. They just hoped that they could be this lucky every night.

 

 

Day 3 Start!




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089