Mafia Round 58: Avatar The Last Airbender

[benao87]

Yoshiya said:

benao87 said:

Nachomamma8 said:

STEFL confirmed scum. Cop linkz, don't protect him because he's probably scum. Don't have a handle on the third scum, but STRONG town are vetterman, yoshiya, spurge, final-fan.

I wish spurge hand't gone berserk, much more could've been achieved day 1.

What do you reckon now?

I think it's safe to lean on Stefl having been town rather than mafia. Poisoner is normally 3rd party (meaning that if he was 3rd party he wouldn't have been targeted by what we assume to be the poisoner) and if he was mafia it would have been unfair not to tell town (what if we lynched him and had no idea we'd actually achieved what we are supposed to do?). That and the way that Mario talks about it being sad in the flavour makes me think that's his way of saying that he's good. On the flip side, you are right to say that we can't confirm him, I just think it's safe to say he probably is.

Yeah, I also though that he might be a 3rd party, but the way FF died is more mafia-like, due to flavour, then his death had to came from a 3rd party.

Maybe it's prudent to think he is town, and assume that all the threats to town are still intact, and we do take extra care.