I thought it was perfect to start, putting bad games like metal gear with good ones like gears.

Of course if we eliminated all the games you think are bad in the first round there wouldn't be much left for anyone to care about in round 2

He's overrated. Time will prove when the next project comes, specially if it isn't made with AAA budget to cover how mediocre it is.

I've voted in all match ups until now, minus 2. With some when I could vote for the 2.. I can evaluate games I dislike just fine. Metal gear would be above cod and not much more.

I don't believe I ever called into question your ability to evaluate what you like and dislike 

I've told you this before, but I keep seeing you bring this up so I guess I'll say it again. You're probably not gonna see the X1 version till launch (or a few days before when somebody gets an early copy). PC centric devs almost never show off anything but the PC version, and when they do, it is pretty much always the version of the most popular console. Reason being simple. For one, that console will have a larger fan base (obviously) to market to, and secondly the console version differences aren't major enough to have a real need to show off both. 

easy round for me - Gears 4

I haven't played MGS since the original Playstation

A B movie vs a bad ass TPS. Delta Squad folks get my vote.
Gears.

You did say that no game would be left if all the games I find bad would be taken out, but that's where you are mistaken and enters my evaluate argument. I can evaluate games I dislike, me disliking something doesn't mean I find them bad. Well cod and metal gear are bad games but something like just cause 3 isn't even if I dislike it I can evaluate it positively. I mean I'm not blind, that's why I take pride on my opinion and arguments.

I think you're taking what I said far too literally. When I said what I said there was no distinction to me between what you consider bad, and what you simply dislike. Especially since you usually have a very matter of factly tone when talking about anything you dislike and basically say it sucks as fact (at least that's how it comes across).

What you're saying now about MGS and CoD just backs this up really. You say they are bad games. Like it's a fact. It's your opinion, which I'm totally fine with, but an opinion nevertheless.

Anyway, my only point was that you really don't care too much about most games getting out of the 1st round, and I meant nothing more by it than that