By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Xbox Empire - New thread up soon!

Slade6alpha said:
I love the prediction section idea Jay!
There's a lot of upcoming games I'd like to see tabled. Like Mordor, Sunset, Halo, etc.

Dat...TRIPLE POST O_o



starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS

Around the Network

OMG I need FH2!!!!!!!! Demo's not enough!

ALSO!!! @Ryuu.. or someone who may know.
Does anyone know when the games for gold for October is released; the list that is? Hopefully we get something good this month. Would be cool to get F5 for free.



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

starcraft said:
Slade6alpha said:
I love the prediction section idea Jay!
There's a lot of upcoming games I'd like to see tabled. Like Mordor, Sunset, Halo, etc.

Dat...TRIPLE POST O_o

A little birdie told me nothing was posted.. so I clicked it again. Then that same little birdie told me that nothing showed up and that he/she was looking at another thread... so i hit it again. 

Hence the triple post



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

crissindahouse said:
EspadaGrim said:
88-90 for FH2, 82-84 for SO and 90-94 for MCC.

MCC so high? There will be a few editors who will love it but also a lot who will complain about how old school it is and stuff like that. Awesome for real Halo fans but I see some editors giving it a 7 or similar scores.


For the amount of content that it has yes i think that it will score that high maybe even higher.



EspadaGrim said:
crissindahouse said:
EspadaGrim said:
88-90 for FH2, 82-84 for SO and 90-94 for MCC.

MCC so high? There will be a few editors who will love it but also a lot who will complain about how old school it is and stuff like that. Awesome for real Halo fans but I see some editors giving it a 7 or similar scores.


For the amount of content that it has yes i think that it will score that high maybe even higher.


Yeah I dont see how an upgrade of 4 highly rated games put together with all content included with extra content too can get anything lower than an 8.



Around the Network

I just came back from gamestop and I put down $350 on my sunset overdrive bundle today, can't wait till October 28!



jlmurph2 said:


Yeah I dont see how an upgrade of 4 highly rated games put together with all content included with extra content too can get anything lower than an 8.


Hopefully reviewers don't cheat this game with BS scores but i wouldn't be surprised if they do.



jlmurph2 said:
EspadaGrim said:


For the amount of content that it has yes i think that it will score that high maybe even higher.


Yeah I dont see how an upgrade of 4 highly rated games put together with all content included with extra content too can get anything lower than an 8.

They are highly rated but that was in the past. That's why I mentioned that some will complain about "old school" feeling.  Halo: CE anniversary has a 82 on Metacritics and would probably get below 80 nowadays. Halo 3 is not even really a remaster and Halo 4 would probably also get some points lower as the 87 it got when it released. Halo 2 anniversary will get the most praise and the whole collection is huge but I still think that some will look too much at every single game and how they think about them and complain that games from the past don't feel how they should nowadays. 

Like I also said it will be an awesome edition for real Halo fans like me but not every editor reviewing it will be an old Halo fan. Maybe some guys like Ryan McCaffrey but there will be enough who aren't Halo fans or even worse, some who prefer the newer Halo games and don't like Halo 1-3 so much^^

I hope I'm wrong but well...



FH2, 89
SO, 84
MCC, 92



starcraft said:
I LOVE GIGGS said:

Example of what I'm going to do moving forward:

 

For the current game (assuming it got 84 on Metacritic):

 

Total:

I'm going to update this table weekly, as more reviews are coming for the game. I'll stop update the result for the game one month after release.

Any suggestion or correction I should make?

I would add a note to the second table that points out that person with the best score is the one closest to a zero average.

My scores for:

Halo: MCC - 91

Fable Legends - 79

Edit: Oh, and SO - 84


Im confused.  Was this post in this thread, because if so how did i miss it?  

Anyways, add Ori and the Blind Forest since its a first party title :)  Ill put it up on the front page whenever its ready