Super Mario 3D Land.

But since HandHelds don't seem to be considered in these lists (Ugh) I'll pick The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword.

I LOVE Skyward Sword but - and I hate myself for this - Skyrim!!!

Xenoblade, which isn't available to vote on the poll. Between these, though, certainly The Witcher 2, altough Portal 2 was also an awesome game.

OP is from Mexico, and XenoBlade released in 2012 here. I would agree with you XenoBlade tops all these games, had it released in 2011 in this region.

For me it's a toss up between Zelda, Gears, and Uncharted. Zelda really surprised me, it's the most "zelda feeling" game I've played since Majora's Mask, and it's one of 2 only games which take advantage of the Wii-mote IMO (the other being Metroid Prime 3). Gears of War 3 was also really fun, but the story ended too suddenly, and kinda poorly IMO. I did love the multiplayer though. Uncharted 3, I haven't played yet, but I hear it's equally as good as Uncharted 2, so juding by that.....

Zelda is my vote

Only 19 out of 176 people played Dark Souls? There simply is no other explanation.

Skyrim
Batman
Uncharted
Portal 2
The Witcher 2

Great year for gaming 2011

Portal 2. A victory for Science

Oh, sure, I forgot about that. It also released in 2012 here in Brazil, but since I bought the European version in 2011 I guess the difference in release dates slipped my mind.

Dark Souls without a second thought. Other fantastic titles on there, but Dark Souls takes fun to a new level.

I played Demon Souls, and hated it. I heard Dark Souls was more of the same. As much as I love the game, and a good challenge, I hate backtracking when I die....