This is probably the hardest question (for me personally) asked on these threads in a long while.... My anticipation for TLOU has grown to a fever pitch.... and reading the GameInformer cover story about GTA5 a few months back cleared up all my worry about that game and grew my anticipation to all new heights... Thank goodness these two games come out many months apart... But to answer the question... For me... I'd go with GTA ONLY because I can see myself playing it many times through and always having a somewhat different experience due to the sandbox environment. But that is not a knock on TLOU at all... It might end of being one of my favorite games this gen... Great thread..

The last of us! :)

Grand Theft Auto, though I'm not really excited for either. I'll rent both.

Not really excited for either of them yet. But I will probably get them both anyways. Too little is shown for both imo.

The Last of Us. That and Beyond: Two Souls will finally make me buy a PS3.

The last of Us.

I tend to get excited about most Sony exclusives.

GTA V

Once I finish The Last of Us, I won't go back to it. GTA will keep me busy for months.

This.. We all have our opinions on replayabity.. I will LOVE both games, maybe the Last of Us more during my first playthrough.. But I just know I will be enjoying GTAV well into next year... Like I said before, it's not a knock on TLoU. It's just GTAV legs are ridiculous. 

The last of us. The last time I was this excited for a game was ffxiii but SE let me down, somewhat :(
But this is Naughty Dog!

Both and i don't think you people should judge GTA V on what GTA IV was, when we have seen only trailers not actual gameplay