By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Bioshock: Infinite- Reviews (95 on Metacritic!), game out now!

 

Where will it end up on Metacritic?

<80 19 4.44%
 
80-83 6 1.40%
 
84-86 20 4.67%
 
87-89 58 13.55%
 
90-92 161 37.62%
 
93+ 164 38.32%
 
Total:428
Conegamer on 25 March 2013
Lostplanet22 said:
So no more reviewers are so negative now right?

Not yet, but as I mentioned below some rreviewers are contradicting themselves. Does look very good, and I'd imagine the story 'saves' it. 

Only 7 reviews for the console versions though. More for PC, but this will likely be reviewed much better than the console versions.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Around the Network
ethomaz on 25 March 2013
Conegamer said:
I think the AusGamer reviewer is going overboard. Best game ever? Infinitely better than OoT? Lets not get ahead of ourselves here...

90-92 on Metacritic seems likely, with 95 or so for the PC version. Does look amazing though.

More like 94 for consoles and 95 for PC... the score in meta is holding up not down.



ethomaz on 25 March 2013
Conegamer said:

Only 7 reviews for the console versions though. More for PC, but this will likely be reviewed much better than the console versions.

9 for PS3... 96 meta... 28 for PC... 95 meta.



Conegamer on 25 March 2013
ethomaz said:

Conegamer said:

I could almost guarantee that GTA V and maybe Wind Waker HD will score higher, looking at the success of previous games in the series.

GTA maybe... Wind Waker HD not.

But I think this year it will not happen... just felling.

The original WW scored 96, and the remake seems to be doing everything right, then more. So it'll likely end up the same. 

I agree that excluding outliers this will end up around 94 or 93, but they'll be some reviewers who will give it a poor score for hits (Quarter to Three?), but iit'll certainly be one of the best games of the gen, and rightly so. So pumped for tomorrow!



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

arcane_chaos on 25 March 2013

96 after 9 reviews...looks like that gonna drop to about the 92-94 when all is said and done...



Around the Network
Lostplanet22 on 25 March 2013
Conegamer said:
Lostplanet22 said:
So no more reviewers are so negative now right?

Not yet, but as I mentioned below some rreviewers are contradicting themselves. Does look very good, and I'd imagine the story 'saves' it. 

Only 7 reviews for the console versions though. More for PC, but this will likely be reviewed much better than the console versions.

contradicting? 

And gametrailers also gave it 9.4. 



 

ethomaz on 25 March 2013

Locking at N4G there are a lot Perfect (10/10) scores to be added to Meta for console version...

 Can this game ends the best scored game ever in Meta? I think 98 is hard to happen again but 96 is a really possibility... TOP10 for now like the first BioShock.



Conegamer on 25 March 2013
Lostplanet22 said:
Conegamer said:
Lostplanet22 said:
So no more reviewers are so negative now right?

Not yet, but as I mentioned below some rreviewers are contradicting themselves. Does look very good, and I'd imagine the story 'saves' it. 

Only 7 reviews for the console versions though. More for PC, but this will likely be reviewed much better than the console versions.

contradicting? 

And gametrailers also gave it 9.4. 

Not really. The combat is good whilst the setting is amazing is what I'm getting out of it.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Aldro on 25 March 2013

Look at the version with the most reviews, that's how its done!

95 atm, I am guessing itll end up around 94-96. It's got A LOT of perfect scores. But two scores are already 8/10 so I think that hinders anything above 96.



ethomaz on 25 March 2013

Conegamer said:

The original WW scored 96, and the remake seems to be doing everything right, then more. So it'll likely end up the same.

I agree that excluding outliers this will end up around 94 or 93, but they'll be some reviewers who will give it a poor score for hits (Quarter to Three?), but iit'll certainly be one of the best games of the gen, and rightly so. So pumped for tomorrow!

HD remakes receive low score than the originals... I can't see the WW HD scoring better than the original WW.

GTA IV is a true game to beat BioShock Infinite and maybe with a little luck The Last of US.