How do you view his (in my opinion) pretty weird argument that only scum would pick up on him blatantly contradicting himself?

Are you implying that Astro and Linkz are on different scum teams here?

So you're saying we should leave someone that is scum alive because he isn't a threat? Last time town did that mafia went in to have a flawless victory. I was starting to seriously consider the possibility that you and Linkz were town fighting it out but after this post I'm not so sure anymore >.>

This has to be one of the most oxymoronic statements I've read in a while haha. Unfortunately for Radish however, knowing him in real life means that I know he starts to act this way when he is uncomfortable (contradicting his own statements, acting forgetful etc.) so from where I am standing it seems like he had something to hide right from the moment he started to contradict himself. As such;

Unvote: DT (This vote is void now anyway considering the reasoning behind it)

Vote: Radishhead

No, you get paranoid.

So you think that town is lazy and scum is tryhard?

I am glad that you did this, still want to see your other reads.

It's a weird argument, but it's an argument that Radish wouldn't have put forth if he didn't feel it felt some validity, regardless of alignment. Scum normally don't throw out arguments that they see obvious flaws in unless they think the town wouldn't pick up on it. I don't think Radish is that type of player, hence it's most likely just Radish logic.

i don't like the latest radish push that much, and I don't like that I feel like all of the vets who i am familiar with aren't really engaging this round, save Linkz.

The mafia members this round are Mario, HD, Yoshiya, Spurge and one of the new players- not sure which one

"I'm not paranoid, I'm just such a threat to mafia that I have to deal with them trying to get me with their mind control powers"

All his reasoning is bs. I've tried to think maybe he could come out clean, but how long did it take for him to come clean on the contradiction, then all the denial.

Forget it man, he is just scum

vote Radish

@Nacho. Hey, glad that pleased you. I try to be reasonable and sensible, doesn't always work. My clearest read is above ^ on radish.

@Yoshiya. Source and it was a strategy that was made clear in the open, if you disagree then explain no need to get suspicious (unless you have an agenda of course).

I'd be happy to source it but before I waste any effort trying to find it, I seem to remember there being a database/thread for all this stuff which makes returning to old games a lot easier. If this does exist would someone with quick access to it be so kind as to post it? If it doesn't exist then just say and I'll look for it myself.

For the record, the game in question was the one I skipped which Hat hosted. Tabaha was clearly scum and everyone agreed on this, however, because they felt he was a weak player they didn't lynch him, which meant that after mislynching that Day and then scum hitting with their Nightkill, he and his scummates (DT and Spurge) won the game without any of them being lynched.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=121381&page=1

Game 49, page 54 (first page I've seen the first comment where people pretty much knew Tabaha was scum).

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=149622&page=54

I'll admit that my memory was a little off on what happened but if you look at the scenerio, pretty much everyone left was under the correct assumption that Tabaha was scum but they kept saying they would leave it until tomorrow, and, as I said, this cost them the game as it allowed mafia to win at the end of that Day.