Posts's like this are what make me think you are scum. Why are you looking at it from a scum perspective instead of a town one?

You probably have laid out a case for this before, but would you mind linking back to why you think that would be a good idea. I did get some scum vibes from him in our first real interactions, but he has managed to make me feel very uncertain about that read. Of course, now having my initial strong read on nen cast into serious doubt means I need to rethink many things that has happened until now.

Well, the perspective is the same from either side. Role claiming would be a very risky move if it's not true. So, role claiming seems like a last resort type of way to prove you are speaking the truth?

Also, I should add that this reasoning assumes that no one in the game, town nor scum, knows for sure what roles are in play. I might not have that fact straight, but that is what I assume.

Well, I joined this round partly to get caught out by Rol again, and it's definitely happened. That was a clever technique, but the thing I said earlier is still true - it doesn't matter if I said Linkz was mafia or town first; the fact that I changed my stance, and that HD noticed it supports my point

His meta this far clearly indicates that he has a knack for reverse psychology. I don't blame you for getting this vibe because I got it too at first glance, but your posting about your suspicion of it surprises me since we're both seeing his meta.

It fortifies my suspicion of you.

As for casting suspicion, town needs to do that as well as foster implicit trust. It's not one of the other so I'm okay with nen casting suspicion where it has its place.

Yeah, I fully trust Nen's claim unless someone else comes forward and says they are the watcher. Unlike last game, where I wanted to get the cop lynched, we are not going to mess around with this.

@Nen
It seems my suspicion for you was unjustified, but it is your fault for looking so suspicious and saying you are always scum. :P

Also, if you quote a post that has a vote in it, please unbold.

Why would town lie if their in a position where they need to role claim?

Town most likely don't know what other roles exist, but they would assume they are the only one that has their role.(Not including Vanillas of course) Like when Stefl responded to Mario's hypothetical about counterclaiming miller.

You are making less sense as this Day goes on. If anything you're applying the meta backwards. If he's good enough to realize scum might use reverse psychology to keep townies from lynching them, then he should be good enough to question why a townie would lie about their role.

You see me jumping on everyone that has suspected others? Nope, just ill-reasoned suspicion that is in the wrong place.

Vote: Nacho

Still suspicious of Spurge. Hatz, Seth, and Noctis.