Rol seems like a pro and was the first to call for his head.  I'd probably lynch almost anyone right now besides myself since this is my first Mafia game...  Looking forward to some action so...

I'm down for lynching FF.

I certainly don't, though as fruitless as I thought your question would be, I was sure not to ruin it's potential. You can acknowledge my response with full seriousness if you'd like. I may choose to "dance" around any questions you have if I don't think the answers should be said though.

I am just curious why you wanted to divert attention back to that.

I already gave my personal opinion on what I think about it.

You are making this up to suit your case, because a) I am fairly certain you admitted to not paying much attention in the early game of that round(and I am going to fact check this) and 2) I was playing catch up most of Day One because of how quickly it exploded. There was no aggression until I was adamant that tabaha would not be lynched due to a BS claim by a stupid day-vig, which was quite a few days after it started.

@Seth
If this wasn't your first Mafia game, you would consider lynching yourself?

Well, but if you don't ask follow-up questions you will hardly spawn any discussion, thanking for others opinions will get you nowhere.

We'll have to meet in the middle because though I was active all game I missed day 2. That's it. I think I pegged you scum early on though (day 1) and it got worse on day 3.

I don't know why you think I'm making this up. They asked me my reads and I gave them. Now you're being critical again, which is a scum tell again (getting aggressive when pegged).

I'll retract that you said you weren't paying attention in the early game. As I said in that game, you simply weren't paying attention to the very things you said yourself. You did admit to not remembering things, so I'll take your misremembering the early part of the round as simply that.

Perhaps you accused me of being scum day 1 or 3,(but pegged is incorrect since I was town) but I know that you had called me town until I proposed the idea of you being Mafia Busdriver, where you did a 180.

1. Perhaps it was unintentional on hat's part, but it's pretty clear you have no idea what I was refering to when I said "I see what you did there."
2. This is worded poorly. Are you saying Yoshiya is acting strangely, thus is probably scum?
3. Mario didn't try to counter claim, but why is it odd?
4. Why is it odd that Stefl claimed Miller so fast? What if Mario is killed instead of lynched, or Nacho/FF claim Miller?
5. Why do you consider that strange and not hat's question towards newbs?

Vote: sethnintendo

Radish is a very strong townread of mine; a lot of his reasons for signing up for the game was proving Linkz wrong and showing that he can participate, and this play so far demonstrates that pretty well. He's also showing the paranoia that town-Radish often shows (last round, Halo), and it's nothing like the panicky scum-Radish in LyLo that we saw in round 50? I think?

I agree with hatmoza that Bong Lover is town for the "transmission received" comment. Sure, all role PMs probably had the same format, but I seriously doubt that a newbie would realize that, and I seriously doubt that his scumteam would coach him instantly into saying something like that. New scum players are usually slow to get started, lay low, that sort of thing.

Stefl's miller claim is fine I don't mind it at all, but the response to mario's fake miller claim feels a bit off. The whole "I would claim miller again and do the same thing!" sounded kind of weird, considering natural response to another miller claim should be "other miller claim is scum".

Mario seems pretty town for the fake miller claim, though. You can see his though process evolve with the "well, what if I claimed miller?" move which was enough to shake Stefl up a bit, and fake counterclaiming what is essentially worse than vanilla role is not really worth sticking your neck out as scum (because if you mess it up, you could get lynched and confirm the miller as town).

I haven't liked sethnintendo's play so far. Maybe it's just a slow start, but the whole "so, we're lynching FF? let's lynch FF!" mantra he's been posting seems like he's too overly focused on the lynch candidate and not really looking anywhere for scum by himself. Benao's been playing similarly, but I like that he isn't trying to jump on the FF wagon like Seth has been.