Okay I'm finally caught up. I'm still juggling with the possibilities in my head but here's where I stand right now.
hatmoza: Took spurge's place thinking he would get to be scum and would be able to kill Final-Fan to end his revenge then proclaimed to be disappointed at being town. Not many bought into this, radish did , Linkz and prof continued to believe he was scum and that's when the cop claim pops up. As I mentionned in my reply to radish (post), we shouldn't lose track of the fact that hatmoza might only be trying to stay alive to fulfill his revenge and what I got from all the argumentation with prof and linkz is that hatmoza is desperate to stay alive (his bargaining his lynch against Linkz's lynch is merely a tool to make himself more convincing in his cop claim). My guess is that hatmoza has some kind of killing ability (probably as scum) and he's willing to do everything he can to make it to the night.
linkzmax: I had a good town vibe from him before I left, so when he countered hat I didn't have any trouble believing him. I have to admit the way he refused to detail exactly what made him go against hat's claim rubbed me the wrong way though.
prof: Strong town vibe out of him. He has been pressing hatmoza with questions and looking at the situation from many angles. I feel a genuine desire to figure what is going on from him.
Marcus: His if x flips town then we lynch y posts [here] and [here] gave me a really scummy vibe. Then more recently [this] and [this] made things worst, especially the first one where he says that he believes hatmoza and I'd be willing to vote for him to prove the doubters wrong... what townie would ever do that? "I believe you're the cop and I'll kill you to prove it" it makes no sense at all.
I'm running out of time and I have to make the next VGC UT thread so I guess my impressions on others will have to wait.