I don't know if we can pull this back, but it's worth a try. I'm thinking we should lynch Mario today, but I don't imagine I'll get much support for this (since my Linkz suspicion didn't turn out so well)

naw radish. no support here. you're more of a suspect then he is.

think about it radish. everyone that's been playing that we've lynched thus far were active players, and you a lurker comes in and makes a suggestion like that is just laughable.

we've yet to lynch any lurkers so i think it's bout time we do.

oh yea, as for the modkills. it almost happened to me. but instead of posting after zero and prof, i just decided to read as they both got modkilled.

 both modkills were justified.

radishhead said: I don't know if we can pull this back, but it's worth a try. I'm thinking we should lynch Mario today, but I don't imagine I'll get much support for this (since my Linkz suspicion didn't turn out so well)

That's funny that, neither of my two main scumspects were the one you chose. But I guess seeing as scum are just one lych away from winning, and need every town to vote against them for the game to not be there's this round, why bother with anyone not scummy? To people saying that I am now suddenly the top of their scum list (look who they are and raise an eyebrow) I ask this, for what reason do you have of that? I have not been playing for a large segment of this round undeniably yes. Though I have had legitimate reasons for it, and two other players can back me up on this, and the mod as well (I informed Stefl the reasoning in an apology -but I would highly doubt he would comment) The reason for me being back now is simple- we just had a long night, I have had a few days of Internet. Free time+ Internet= ability to have a working knowledge of where the game is at. Similarly we are now down to 4 townies. To lynch, we need four townies. It would not be fair of me to cause a town loss by inactivity preventing town from lynching.

The reason why I only mentioned trucks and FF is because those are the only two players I have got a scum read off that I would vote and potentially lose on.

Reasoning for Trucks: 1) He is still alive, and probably the last active player who as town, would be considered "a threat". Scum had the oppotunity to see how the game was going to play out as the modkills occurred midnight. They need a single mislynch. Why would they leave the last active townie with serious weight and experience when you consider the rest of the players still around?
Now you could make the case that they must have seen Noctis was doc and this killed him- but why would they? Noctis hasn't been over the top active, and they don't need to kill him. You kill the doc to ensure nightkills. THEY DON'T NEED ANYMORE NIGHTKILLS. So no, you can't make that case.
For all over reasons, read back the thread around page 27ish. I'm not going to make myself seem more engaged by parroting other people's points- I'm on mobile and it's two much hassle when they are right there. Trucks being scum isn't a new idea

MARCUSDJACKSON said: think about it radish. everyone that's been playing that we've lynched thus far were active players, and you a lurker comes in and makes a suggestion like that is just laughable. we've yet to lynch any lurkers so i think it's bout time we do.

I'll give you support on this if final fan is the lurker. I can't take a morale high ground - but I've had legit reasons and have stated I have had them. You have regularly said that my reads last game were very good. My final fan suspicion is like my Stefl one from last game. Had it since the start and it has stayed. Not the greatest reason , but trust me on this-I had my reasons for suspecting him, even if I can't explain them right now in a logical fashion worth the sleep time.

 

MARCUSDJACKSON said: i really don't like how radish, DT, and Yoshia just random post after lurking. it's a ploy to conceal themselves as mafia. i've been rightlot this so one if not all of these 3 are mafia.

First off the bat- not all three would be mafia. Primarily because I'm am not, and secondly because a scum team of all lurkers doesn't happen. Scum often seem more active because they have more to gain from paying attention and stirring up trouble. 

 

Another pony with terrible reasoning before I start I acknowledge. (yes I'm bringing up the dreaded numbers Yoshiya :P) usually one out of myself radish and Yoshiya are scum as long as all three of us are playing. So it wouldn't surprise me if one of the two of them was scum, but I wouldn't vote on that "logic" and I'm not sure which one yet either. I have reasons to suspect both( more leaning radish but don't hold me too that could be another person) 

DarkThanatos said: MARCUSDJACKSON said: think about it radish. everyone that's been playing that we've lynched thus far were active players, and you a lurker comes in and makes a suggestion like that is just laughable. we've yet to lynch any lurkers so i think it's bout time we do. I'll give you support on this if final fan is the lurker. I can't take a morale high ground - but I've had legit reasons and have stated I have had them. You have regularly said that my reads last game were very good. My final fan suspicion is like my Stefl one from last game. Had it since the start and it has stayed. Not the greatest reason , but trust me on this-I had my reasons for suspecting him, even if I can't explain them right now in a logical fashion worth the sleep time.

could you get behind a FF vote? 

DT so you could get behind a radish vote?